Just so we are all dealing with the real data.
Andy's injury history.
2004-2005 out jan 26 to march 6
2005-2006 did not play until jan 27
2006-2007 no significant injury time
2007-2008 jan 30 to Feb 24
2008 2009, no significant injury time
2009-2010 no significant time
all of the above were playoff years
2010-2011 out jan 5 rest of season
2011-2012 out feb 11 rest of season
2012-2013 out dec 19 rest of season
2013-2014 out jan28 so far..
Last years issues were an exception as he had a life threatening condition from a oddball injury. But i think the front office made a decision in the non playoff years not to push Andy to preserve his longevity.
If Andy returns and continues to play, it will be because the FO really thinks we can make the playoffs. if our trajectory is not there, i think they pull Andy for the season. Similar with Dion, less so with Miles.
when we talk about trading Andy, that is always possible, but his value elsewhere is perhaps lower than his value here. I think signing Andy is a no brainer if he wants to stay on, but I dont think it is a giant contract.