Both are very similiar players. JRich is 27 years old so he is younger and also is a better defender (arguably) but with Carter you know what you get. You get a legit 20 5 5 guy almost every night but you also get a bad defender. In this late in his career could a coach that demands defense get carter to play defense? They both have long expensive contracts that interfer with our cap space for 2010. Is this a risk worth taking to win now? Also which would you rather have?