We need to get healthy now. I stil would love another starting pitcher.
Why?
Post All-Star break we are trotting out by far the best starting rotation in the AL, if not in all of baseball. In the 28 starts the Indians rotation has made since the break, they are 1st in WAR, 1st in FIP, 1st in K/9, 2nd in ERA, 2nd in WHIP, 2nd in BB/9, and are 12-4.
Combined our starters have a FIP below 3 in 171 combined IP in the 2nd half, which is absolutely bonkers for a single player to post, let alone a combination of 6 different pitchers.
Salazar is healthy and dealing, Bauer is dealing, Cookie is Cookie, Kluber is the best starter in baseball, and both guys who have filled in as the #5 have been fine themselves.
If you are worried about one of them blowing up, worry about it later. Right now, enjoy the best starting rotation in baseball since the break. This team does not need another starter right now, not with the Salazar and Bauer we are seeing right now.