I always want to ask Jon Niednagel -- who famously predicted Peyton Manning would be great and Ryan Leaf would be a bust back in 1998, and who insisted Brady only excelled because of Belichick --, why he thought Manning was better than Montana all-time (Niednagel was insistent that Peyton Manning was by far the greatest QB in NFL history). He had Manning and Montana as both ESTP, the top QB type per his expertise. (Brady is classified as ENFP, same as Drew Brees; he and Brees are the only QBs to excel with that type whereas many other good QBs have been ESTP historically.) Was Manning the best because of his size and strength? But what about mobility? Joe was so darn smooth. Like you, I only got to directly observe him during his last years, but when I watch all the highlights, I see more mobility than with Manning. Joe loved the rollouts.
I think so. Spielman in there too.
