I stand by what I said a few weeks ago.
If Jedrick Wills had played left tackle all year, he would have been the unanimous OT1 in this year's draft because he had, in my opinion, the consistently best tape of the top four guys.
Andrew Thomas was the safest pick of the bunch because he didn't have any projection to his evaluation. He's a simple plug and play LT.
I totally bought into Tristan Wirfs from an athletic and scheme fit perspective. I really thought for sure he was going to be the pick, but the fact is his tape just had a lot of inexplicably terrible reps that I just can't explain. A guy who was basically stronger and more athletic than the guy trying to get past him on nearly every rep just having complete fundamental breakdowns at times. I maintain that Wirfs' very best A+ reps are better than Wills or Thomas' very best A+ reps because of the athleticism advantage, but consistency is the name of the game along the OL.
Becton was the home run swing. If he keeps his weight under control and really dedicates himself to being great, he may very well end up being the best of the bunch because of his size + strength + speed combo. But he also has the biggest chance of washing out IMO.
Wills is more athletic than Thomas and had better tape than Wirfs. Best of both worlds hopefully.