• Changing RCF's index page, please click on "Forums" to access the forums.

2023 Cleveland Guardians Season Thread

Do Not Sell My Personal Information
I have a hunch, going into the off season we will look for another OF, but at the moment, Kwan and Brennan have starting spots with Laureano and Straw on the bench/last OF spot. If we acquire someone then the 4 OFs will change ..

If the Guardians are truly serious about winning in 2024, Will Brennan should NOT have a starting spot locked in for next season.

I like Will ok, but the Guardians should assume right now they only have one everyday outfielder in Kwan.
 
I like Brennan as the 4th OF, with Kwan in LF and Laureano in CF, if and only if you can get a power bat in RF from outside the organization.

Too bad Naylor couldn't remain in RF with Manzo coming up eventually.
 
Joe Noga had this little tidbit today:

Since May 30, Cleveland has out-hit its opponents in 57 games and ranks tied for second in the AL with 42 games of 10 or more hits.

So I checked and since May 30 the Guardians rank 5th in the majors in team batting average at .262. The bad news is they rank 15th in runs, obviously due to a lack of power and maybe poor situational hitting. Like I said in another thread, 20 of Will Brennan's last 23 hits have been singles; the other 3 were doubles. Kwan and Straw, of course, are singles hitters.

From the start of the season until May 29 the G's ranked 28th in batting average at .227. So they've gone from 28th in April/May to 5th from June until now and that's with Josh Naylor missing the month of August. Getting rid of Zunino, Bell, and Oscar really helped. Bringing up Bo Naylor and Will Brennan getting hot in the last month also helped.

The question is whether they can carry this into next year and be a top five team in batting average while adding a little pop.
 
Last edited:
If the Guardians are truly serious about winning in 2024, Will Brennan should NOT have a starting spot locked in for next season.

I like Will ok, but the Guardians should assume right now they only have one everyday outfielder in Kwan.

I don't see Cleveland just throwing out Brennan right now, since that's what they would be doing. He will add more power in due time and walks as well since he was known for taking walks all through the minors...

Michael Brantley didn't start hitting lefties nor for power until essentially his second full season in the bigs and honestly, I think Brennan on paper, will be a better overall player in 24 than he was in 23.

Cleveland has DeLauter and Valera with J Rodriquez and OGonz also in the mix... I am saying Brennan is a lock to start spring as one of the OFs beside Kwan, but it doesn't mean someone cannot take his spot. We are only going to acquire 1 OF that could be a starter at most. We cannot afford to try and replace 2 starts in 24 since that would essentially could block DeLauter, who I think is the future of Cleveland but I cannot expect him to be around til 25...

Aka 24... Kwan, Brennan then comp for the other spot... We internally have Noel, Valera, J Rodriquez, OGonz, Laureano, Straw, possibly Freeman and Brito added out there and we will look to maybe trade for an external player as well...

IF we don't make a trade, Brennan for sure has a spot... He can lose said spot if he doesn't show improvement and Cleveland felt like they could trade Jones and Benson because they had faith in Brennan to become an everyday player. They aren't just going to give up on him now. He will get another season to prove himself and if he fails, then they will move on...
 

Bibee's rookie season has come to an end.

10-4 with a 2.98 ERA in 25 starts. 141 strikeouts in 142 innings pitched.

He was near the innings limit in my mind anyways, so this really isn't a huge issue.

He's second in bWAR for all AL rookies at the moment... Gunnar Henderson though is the ROY so Bibee and Volpe are fighting for the 2 and 3rd spots on paper...
 
Its great seeing DeLauter hit his way into the 2024 plans. That said he could be special and they should play the service time game with him next season and wait to call him up until mid June. They have a ton of guys in front of him they need to see first.
 
He was near the innings limit in my mind anyways, so this really isn't a huge issue.

He's second in bWAR for all AL rookies at the moment... Gunnar Henderson though is the ROY so Bibee and Volpe are fighting for the 2 and 3rd spots on paper...
Is Volpe really up for it? I get he's been playing SS all year but he's been such a bad hitter.
 
Chase DeLauter Bats: L
AGE 21 DOB 10/08/2001

HT 6' 4" WT 235
DRAFTED
2022, 1st (16) - CLE

ETA 2025

Scouting grades: Hit: 55 | Power: 60 | Run: 55 | Arm: 60 | Field: 55 | Overall: 55

Barely recruited as a West Virginia high schooler, DeLauter attended James Madison and became the first first-rounder in Dukes history after batting .402/.520/.715 in three years. The pandemic limited his first two seasons and a broken left foot shortened his third, but he proved himself with wood bats by leading the Cape Cod League in homers (nine) and slugging (.589) in the summer of 2021. He reinjured his foot after signing for $3.75 million as the 16th overall pick, leading to surgery to replace a screw with a bone graft in January and putting his pro debut on hold until midseason 2023.

The 6-foot-4, 235-pound DeLauter offers a rare combination of size, athleticism, plate discipline and performance. His bat speed, strength and leverage combine to give him well above-average raw power to all parts of the ballpark, and he lets his power come naturally with an extremely disciplined approach. Scouts aren't enamored of his tendency to get long with his left-handed swing [that's my Zimmer worry] or to drift onto his front foot, but that hasn't stopped him from making a lot of hard contact.

DeLauter possesses solid speed and translates it into basestealing ability and center-field range. Some scouts think he's destined for right field, where his plus power and arm strength would fit the classic profile. He delivered low-90s fastballs when he pitched sporadically in college.
 
Fangraphs has a column that includes an interview with Gavin Williams about his fastball. Here's a portion:

The Fayetteville, North Carolina native first hit triple digits during his freshman year at East Carolina University, and as meaningful as that milestone was to his identity on the mound, he recognizes that retiring big-league hitters takes more than pure velocity.

“I don’t think 96 to 100 is that big of a difference,” Williams said. “If it’s down the middle it can get hit. Putting it where you want to is a bigger thing. It also matters how it moves.”

Williams gets good ride — “anywhere between 16 and 18 vert” — and he also possesses elite perceived velocity. Per Statcast, he ranks in the 99th percentile for extension, an attribute that only began augmenting his heater this season.

“It has changed big time from last year to this year,
” explained Williams, who debuted with the Guardians on June 21 and has a 3.43 ERA and a 4.22 FIP over 76 big-league innings. “Last year it was 6-5 extension, and this year it is more like 7-5. We fixed some things mechanically. I’m staying more connected to the rubber now. I’m not cutting myself off; I’m staying more direct to the plate.”

Williams answered “absolutely” when I asked if he identifies as a power pitcher, and Carl Willis used the same term when appraising the highly-regarded youngster. According to Cleveland’s pitching coach, what the hard-thrower mostly needs is more repetitions against baseball’s best hitters.

“He’s got the power, and he spins the ball well, so t’s just a matter of gaining more experience,” said Willis. “With experience comes consistency. A pitcher with good stuff can out-stuff a hitter in the minors, but t’s a lot more difficult to do that at this level. There are some things you just can’t replicate in the minor leagues. The more major-league hitters he’ll face, the more comfortable he’ll get, and the more consistent he’s going to get. He’s got a chance to be a really good pitcher up here.”
 
He was not.

He was going to finish out the season and be under by a decent bit. All 3 rookies were set up to finish out the season without being shutdown.
Yeah, but can I ignore this information for the thirtieth time and tomorrow bring up how they're all approaching a specific innings limit that only exists in my head?

Asking for a friend.
 
He was not.

He was going to finish out the season and be under by a decent bit. All 3 rookies were set up to finish out the season without being shutdown.
On the topic of Bibee's corresponding roster move: If you can answer, do you think Karinchak will be on the Guardians next year?
 

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Video

Episode 3:6 "Take THAT, LeBronto Raptors!"

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Spotify

Episode 3:6 "Take THAT, LeBronto Raptors!"
Top