2025 Season | Series #6 | Guardians @ Orioles | April 15-17, 2025

Wham with the Right Hand

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Oct 3, 2019
Messages
13,145
Reaction score
39,522
Points
148
After sweeping the White Sox and winning their second series from the Royals the Guardians pack their bags for their second road trip. Following this six-gamer the G’s will have played 15 of their first 21 games on the road. If they’re in first or second place after this trip I’d say they’re in great shape.

First stop is Baltimore. The O’s are 6-9 overall and have lost 7 of their last 10. In those 10 games they hit .197/.578. After scoring 32 runs in their first five games they’ve scored only 23 in their last 10. Not hard to figure that run per game average.

That being said, their main problem is starting pitching. The O’s starters rank 29th in ERA and last in average exit velocity and hard hit percentage. The staff as a whole ranks 27th in WHIP and OPS. Their defense isn’t helping; it ranks 27th according to Fangraphs. The first two starters the Guardians face have ERA’s of 8.78 and 8.16.

Their best starter has been Zach Eflin (2-1, 3.00) and he just went on the IL. He joins injured starters Grayson Rodriguez and Kyle Bradish, who have yet to throw a pitch this year.

Offensively the O’s are 12th in runs per game at 4.40 but as noted earlier, they were great the first five games and awful the last 10. They are 13th in home run percentage and 15th in extra base hit percentage, so they’re average in the power department. They’re pretty much average across the board offensively if you look at all 15 games.

Cedric Mullins is off to a great start hitting .277/.967. Mullins has 16 RBI’s; none of his teammates have more than 8. Mullins used to be their leadoff hitter but he’s been primarily their #5 hitter so far this year.

LF Tyler O’Neill is at .289/.899. C Adley Rutschmann is at .259/.807 and 3B Ramon Urias is at .343/.782. The 30-year-old Urias hit .254/.745 last year, which is right on his career numbers. 11 of his 12 hits have been singles.

Star shortstop Gunnar Henderson is off to a slow start at .206/.523. Get him before he gets going.

The pitching matchups are:

Logan Allen (0-1, 3.60) vs. Charlie Morton (0-3, 8.78).
Gavin Williams (1-0, 3.46) vs. Dean Kremer (1-2, 8.16)
Tanner Bibee (1-1, 4.40) vs. Tomoyuki Sugano (1-1, 3.86)

The O’s have struggled against lefties, hitting .213/.551 against a more robust .242/.723 against right-handers. So Allen might have a good outing against them. Mullins is 1-for-7 against lefties.

Allen has only started two games. He was roughed up by the Padres and dominated the White Sox. Offensively the O’s are somewhere in between those teams.

Morton, a 41-year-old right-hander, is getting smacked around pretty good. In three starts he’s allowed 13 earned runs in 13.1 innings. His home run to fly ball ratio is 21% against a career average of 12%. His Stuff+ grade is an 86, meaning his pitchers have been 14% easier to hit than the average pitcher. He has 17 strikeouts so he can still miss bats, but the long ball has been getting him.

The Guardians have momentum having won 5 of 6 while the O’s have negative momentum after losing 7 of 10 and averaging 2.3 runs per game. All three Baltimore starters this series are right-handed and the Guardians are loaded with left-handed hitters, so it seems the Guardians have the edge, especially with how badly the Birds have been swinging the bats lately. Barely any offense and second to worst starting pitching is not a good combination.

The Guardians appear to be catching the Birds at a good time. Hopefully they can win the series. Just win every series 2-1 and you’ll be fine at the end of the season.
 
The Guardians appear to be catching the Birds at a good time. Hopefully they can win the series. Just win every series 2-1 and you’ll be fine at the end of the season.
Perhaps. I generally don't like playing talented teams after they've struggled. I pray we can sneak in there and get two before their bats wake up.
 
I could understand if this were 1969, but now? Up until recently they were doormats in the AL East, what's to hate? That they let Michael Reghi go?
I live here. I tried to be indifferent to them, but then I just ended up hating them. I see a lot of Orioles gear. It makes me want to punch people.
 
Arguably a better ballpark... Even with our upgrades...
 
The Indians of the 90s owe a debt to the great Orioles teams of the 60s and 70s,and it is named Hank Peters.

It's still fantastic to have vanquished them with regularity over the past few decades.
 
Camden Yards is an absolute gem. It has not been surpassed in its 3 decades.
I do think it has taken a step back in its elegance with its nutty left field shenanigans over the last couple of years.
 
Amazingly, The Athletic's Power Poll out today has the O's ranked 13th, although they are 6-9 and have won just 3 of their last 10 games.

13. Baltimore Orioles (13.3)

Record: 6-9
Last Power Ranking: T-11

What might actually be a problem: The rotation just doesn’t have the goods

Ken Rosenthal already made the point last week, but it’s worth reiterating: The Orioles did not act aggressively enough to replace Corbin Burnes. Baltimore’s back-end veteran acquisitions in Tomoyuki Sugano and Charlie Morton have looked like back-end veteran acquisitions. Grayson Rodriguez is hurt, joining the longer-term absences of Kyle Bradish and Tyler Wells. All will eventually be back: Rodriguez probably in May, Bradish and Wells for the second half. But the rotation still lacks that reliable arm, which, look, we like Zach Eflin as much and probably more than the next guy, but he’s not exactly our idea of a No. 1 starter for an October contender.

And Eflin is also injured.
 
Amazingly, The Athletic's Power Poll out today has the O's ranked 13th, although they are 6-9 and have won just 3 of their last 10 games.
These power polls are always interesting, as they are a good measure of general public perception and shallow media assessments.

I'll look at the robot updates for dispassionate guidance instead.

PECOTA (as of 4-14) still has Baltimore projected at 85-77 with a 51% chance of making the playoffs and 22% chance of winning the AL East
(Cleveland is projected to finish fourth in the Central with a 79-83 record, 21% chance of making the playoffs, 12% winning the division)

Baseball Reference (as of 4-15) has Baltimore projected at 76-86 with a paltry 15% chance of making the playoffs and a 3.4% divisional chance.
(Cleveland is projected to finish third in the Central with a .500 record, a 44% chance of making the playoffs, 7% winning the division)

Fangraphs (as of 4-15) has Baltimore projected at 81-81 with a 36% chance of making the playoffs and a 12% chance of winning the AL East.
(Cleveland is projected to finish fourth in the Central with an 80-82 record, 29% chance of making the playoffs, 14% winning the division.

Baseball Reference is considerably bleaker about the Orioles, and more optimistic about the Tribe, but neither club seems to be in the good graces of the objective models at this point (outside of PECOTA's continuing optimism that the O's remain a coin flip to make the postseason) making this series fairly important for an April match-up, if only to get an edge in tie-breakers between two somewhat similarly-situated "contenders."
 
Last year, the AL third WC was decided by one game. The home team for the 2/3 WC was decided by a tie breaker.

In the NL, the second and third WCs were decided by a three team tie breaker, and home team for the 2/3 WC was decided by a tie breaker.

While its way too early to put a major emphasis on any series, every game does count...more than they used to before the addition of the second two WCs.

It seems counter intuitive on the surface, but the more divisions that are added and the more WCs that are added, the more watered down the playoffs become, and the more of a crap shoot it becomes.....but, as the playoffs have expanded, the individual games have become more important.
 
Back
Top