I don't want to get into a conversation around this idea because it's obviously a fantasy, but I have a question. If Cleveland could afford to take on those salaries wouldn't it be more prudent to extend Bieber and pick up another FA or 2 in the offseason? I'm not suggesting anyone is better than Trout, but he's 31 yrs old I believe and struggles to stay healthy. Obviously one of the most dynamic players to ever step foot on a baseball field though.
In the end the idea is fun to think about, but I'm guessing it would set this team back for years. I always thought if Trout were traded he would end up in Philly.
I was gonna answer this question here since it can be a GM question...
It would sincerely depend on which mindset you are looking at things from. If you think you can win now, you would extend Bieber and pay for a Trout, but if you didn't think you could win now, you could always wait a little longer to see what you had in 23 and really finalize the roster in 24...
If you had the money, extending Bieber, I feel like is always 100% the right choice... Now how to let's say how to spend/acquire the rest of it, I would look at needs and what we would need going forward.
Really our needs are upgrading C and getting a bat to protect JRam. I personally feel like free agency can be a big waste of financial/cap since many times in free agency you are signing a player whose over 30 and due money. So it would really depends on the market and needs... I'd rather find a way to acquire someone under long term control rather than try to play the market since it doesn't mean you always get that player you want.
If I was running the roster, majority of the roster will always come through minors/trades/waivers with supplements in Free Agency to finish the roster.
Let's say hypothetical Cleveland had the chance to extend Bieber and get Trout plus Ohtani for non-26 man guys (outside of let's say prospects and/or like OGonz). As an owner, even of a small market, can you skip on that when you add two All-star pieces that make you a frontrunner now?
Now if I couldn't get Trout and Ohtani but the big man said yes to a 60 million increase to spending... You are sure going to find a way to really upgrade the roster and with you being a playoff team, you want to do it sooner rather than later. So in Cleveland's case, Bieber will get an extension and sincerely, I wouldn't be surprised to see Cleveland maybe go for a rental and/or someone normally out of reach... I really don't think they would wait a season, unless they really couldnt find a deal within reason... I know I wouldn't if I was running a roster and though I am a trade aholic in a sense, I don't normally go get the All-Stars of the world, I normally just keep swapping to find the right mix of players.
Now, I am looking at the free agent list in 24...
The best players are SPs and at the moment no real batting talent that's better than what's you have. I'd say for Cleveland they gotta upgrade via internally or trade not via FA on paper. If there was more big name bats then that would be a different matter. Heck, I would have gotten a Trea Turner last off season, regardless of the talent in my system...
You would have to play out who will be available as well and right now, they need to get JRam help and that won't come free agency even if the budget it increased...