With my second pick I take my second HOF pitcher - Bob Lemon.
Won 20+ games 7 times in 9 seasons between 1948 and 1956. Led the American League 5 times in complete games, 3 times in wins, 4 times in innings pitched and was a 7 time All Star. For the Indians he's 3rd in career WAR for pitchers, 3rd in career wins, 4th in complete games and tied for 3rd in shutouts.
Best year is tough, but I'll take 1948 - 20-14, 2.82 era, 20 complete games*, 10 shutouts*, 293 IP, 1.22 WHIP*, and 144 era+. (*Led American League)
He went 2-0 with a 1.65 era and a complete game in the 1948 World Series.