• Changing RCF's index page, please click on "Forums" to access the forums.

Early 22 GM Thread! (Trade Ideas here)

Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Hell, we can apply "what ifs" to a number of guys. He's a good pitcher with limited ability. I don't know what else you want me to say.

Please don't compare Morgan with Kluber. They are and were entirely different profiles.

I wasn't comparing them, I was just stating that if Morgan can find another pitch like Kluber did, he won't be a number 5...

Also what's ironic is Morgan was a higher rated prospect than Kluber or Plesac was, but that's a different matter lol

Then again Civale was ranked higher than Bieber, Plesac, Kluber etc... So the system has some flaws
 
I wasn't comparing them, I was just stating that if Morgan can find another pitch like Kluber did, he won't be a number 5...

Also what's ironic is Morgan was a higher rated prospect than Kluber or Plesac was, but that's a different matter lol
If he can "find" another pitch and not throw his FB on anything but the black then maybe he could surprise, but I don't see it happening and there's a boatload of SP prospects getting very close. I'll take the likelihood that Allen has developed better control and is a better MLB SP.

I'd love nothing more if Morgan pitched like a #3. I am a Guardian fan after all, but if he's starting games regularly then something(s) didn't go as planned. I will say this though, I'd gladly slot Eli in the #5 spot if one of Plesac or Civale were traded for a big bat with years of control.
 
If he can "find" another pitch and not throw his FB on anything but the black then maybe he could surprise, but I don't see it happening and there's a boatload of SP prospects getting very close. I'll take the likelihood that Allen has developed better control and is a better MLB SP.

I'd love nothing more if Morgan pitched like a #3. I am a Guardian fan after all, but if he's starting games regularly then something(s) turned to shit......again.

At the current moment he is the 6th starter and honestly we will see him anytime we get double headers more than likely. It's his spot to lose at the moment. He's the first man up whether or not you like it and I think he deserved that after last season. No he doesn't have the talent the other guys do, but a 4.37 ERA in the last 13 starts with a 3.90 in his last what 5-6 starts
 
At the current moment he is the 6th starter and honestly we will see him anytime we get double headers more than likely. It's his spot to lose at the moment. He's the first man up whether or not you like it and I think he deserved that after last season. No he doesn't have the talent the other guys do, but a 4.37 ERA in the last 13 starts with a 3.90 in his last what 5-6 starts
Well....you're entitled to you opinion. My opinion hasn't changed. Where Eli Morgan fits will determined moreso by others than Eli himself. That's what happens when you're surrounded by more talented players.
 
Well....you're entitled to you opinion. My opinion hasn't changed. Where Eli Morgan fits will determined moreso by others than Eli himself. That's what happens when you're surrounded by more talented players.

I'm going with MLB experience as my 6 man...

If Logan Allen, Hentges etc aren't stretched out, then Morgan is automatically the next man up. Morris and Myers have to take it from him and while they have more talent, Morgan is definitely ahead of them when it comes to MLB ready.

We will see once the spring/season starts, but under normal circumstances Morgan is the next man up. I will worry when I see Battenfield in Cleveland in 22 since that means there is a bunch of injuries...
 
I'm going with MLB experience as my 6 man...

If Logan Allen, Hentges etc aren't stretched out, then Morgan is automatically the next man up. Morris and Myers have to take it from him and while they have more talent, Morgan is definitely ahead of them when it comes to MLB ready.

We will see once the spring/season starts, but under normal circumstances Morgan is the next man up. I will worry when I see Battenfield in Cleveland in 22 since that means there is a bunch of injuries...
It doesn't mean there's a bunch of injuries if Battenfield is up. He's simply a very talented SP that has been extraordinary upon his arrival and really prior to it. Regardless, you'll probably see Pilkington first since he's already on the 40 and is similar to Battenfield. There's Morris too, but his IP will be limited as we discussed. Myers is right there with them as well.
 
Hentges is no longer a starter. He will get a shot at being a back end reliever.

*********

Things won't have gone wrong if one of Battenfield, Myers, or Pilkington pass up Morgan. Just as things didn't go wrong when Clevinger, Bieber, Civale, and Plesac passed Plutko, Merritt, and Morimando.

*********

Under no realistic circumstances would I trade Plesac for two unproven prospects. The drop off from a SP who produces at a level 15% above average to one who pitches at a level 18% below average is too severe.

While we see room to grow for Morgan, who turns 26 in May, why don't folks see room for growth from Plesac, whose 27th birthday is today? Its not like we are talking about a three or four year age difference.

As pointed out earlier, we saw tons of growth from Kluber, Carrasco, Clevinger, Lee, and Bauer after they turned 27.
 
Last edited:
Well....you're entitled to you opinion. My opinion hasn't changed. Where Eli Morgan fits will determined moreso by others than Eli himself. That's what happens when you're surrounded by more talented players.
You continue to talk about Morgan as if he is what he is, that's why I said you talk about him like a 30yo journeyman. Others dictate his fate etc.
LS Allen can improve this that...why can't Morgan improve?, as he's actually shown to adapt and improve much more in a shorter period of time than Allen or Hentges did over years.
 
I'm going with MLB experience as my 6 man...

If Logan Allen, Hentges etc aren't stretched out, then Morgan is automatically the next man up. Morris and Myers have to take it from him and while they have more talent, Morgan is definitely ahead of them when it comes to MLB ready.

We will see once the spring/season starts, but under normal circumstances Morgan is the next man up. I will worry when I see Battenfield in Cleveland in 22 since that means there is a bunch of injuries...
..or a bunch of trades...

InRe Stretched Out: Could be that Morris, Myers and Morgan.. our M & M & M boys make up the fifth spot in the rotation presented as a rotation of these M'ers as the starter/follower/pen-long man. This would pretty much cover 6 to 8 innings every fifth day.. thereby keeping the bullpen rested.. and allowing these younger guys the chance to get stretched out while starting / playing every fifth day..

The net effect is a four man starting rotation and a bit of creativity fifth slot..

Thoughts?..
 
Hentges was a big, northern, left handed kid....the epitome of a slow developer. Most players and pitchers drafted out of Northern climes take a long time to develope.

************

Gsons idea is interesting, but nearly impossible to implement...and probably counter productive.

First of all, using a three man piggy back would mean that seven pitchers would be limited to working once every five days...which limits the amount of true relievers that can be carried...putting more strain on the relievers that remain, and limits Titos ability to go situational.

Throwing two or three IP every five days won't stretch out anybody...and would cut down on development.

Lets say 32 piggyback games....8 innings each....256 combined IP for three pitchers. IMO that won't prepare them for a full load in 2023.
 
..or a bunch of trades...

InRe Stretched Out: Could be that Morris, Myers and Morgan.. our M & M & M boys make up the fifth spot in the rotation presented as a rotation of these M'ers as the starter/follower/pen-long man. This would pretty much cover 6 to 8 innings every fifth day.. thereby keeping the bullpen rested.. and allowing these younger guys the chance to get stretched out while starting / playing every fifth day..

The net effect is a four man starting rotation and a bit of creativity fifth slot..

Thoughts?..

From analyzing the roster, are 40 is not even close to being set. I really do think a 3-4 prospect swap for an OF (and maybe with a C involved or a separate trade for a C) we only have 17 pitchers at the moment on the 40 man, one is likely to be sent to the 60 Day DL, and along with Naylor's spot as well, that makes us at the current moment have spots for 18 pitchers. I don't doubt this gets changed once the ability to make moves opens back up...

@CDAV45 as well since this isn't something we actually looked at yet, so with nothing better to do, let's get into our little fun debates haha

I just noticed that our pitching staff is actually set on paper. I know we will make moves, but if you look, we have the 17 pitchers, one out, so our starting and bullpen is essentially

SPs: Bieber, Civale, Plesac, Quantrill, TMac
Bullpen: Clase, Karinchak, Gose, Allen, Hentges, Sandlin, Stephan

Making it likely Vargas goes onto the 60 day DL...Pilkington, Morgan, Morris and Myers all to the minors.. so we only have 12 projected pitchers for 13 spots...

Whats interesting is Allen, Hentges, Sandlin and Stephan all likely will be multiple inning guys...

I actually think we would be a legit destination for veteran bullpen arms and I wouldn't even be surprised to see a guy like a Broom, Garza, Scott,
Mikolajchak get a big league roster spot out of camp.

Hentges was a big, northern, left handed kid....the epitome of a slow developer. Most players and pitchers drafted out of Northern climes take a long time to develope.

************

Gsons idea is interesting, but nearly impossible to implement...and probably counter productive.

First of all, using a three man piggy back would mean that seven pitchers would be limited to working once every five days...which limits the amount of true relievers that can be carried...putting more strain on the relievers that remain, and limits Titos ability to go situational.

Throwing two or three IP every five days won't stretch out anybody...and would cut down on development.

Lets say 32 piggyback games....8 innings each....256 combined IP for three pitchers. IMO that won't prepare them for a full load in 2023.

Actually his idea isn't all that farfetched but you have it wrong... every 5th start in what he would be proposing would be more like a Stephan-Allen combo then into the bullpen. I actually see Allen and Hentges being effective as early relievers since our starting staff is right handed and having those two coming in often to face a lineup to face that type of lineup actually may be effective.

We don't lack arm talent in the pitching department but it's hard not to notice we have little depth in the bullpen.. depending on the timing of the trade I believe we will make, it actually wouldn't surprise me if we take someone in the Rule 5 draft like we did with Stephan..

If I was able to get off a trade before the Rule 5 draft I'd say RHP Matt Tabor from Arizona would be my choice... and also if I had a second spot maybe even C Blake Hunt from the Rays, he's a defensive first one sadly, but with upside. I think around who we have in place, he could develop fairly well as a catcher.... (now this is if we have open spots before the Rule 5).

We really do need to bring in a veteran relief pitcher, hopefully with closing experience...
 
Also @CATS44 @Gson @CDAV45

Once things get back to being open, who are your free agent targets?...

First off I still think my first target would be LHP Andrew Chafin...

Next it would be bringing in the Shaw, Parker's of the world. Tomlin, Kintzler, Joe Smith, Andrew Miller etc... best talent possible for minor league deal with invites to the major league club and opt outs.. Duffy is another guy I think I would get into camp and have incentives, mid season opt out and whatnot. I want to bring in as many good veterans as possible who have good leadership abilities. We are a really young team so adding experience in my mind is a must...

Next on the docket... catchers... In free agency not much there, but bringing in someone like Greiner i think is necessary at the end of the day...

Next on my list of course is spending Blitzer's money on Bryant... if that does work then Suzuki... if that doesn't work then realistically...I am thinking Andrew McCutchen... or Michael Conforto to man our LF... plus then bring in a guy like Locastro on a minor league deal (he's likely out until July/Aug). Also maybe see if we can get a Marwin Gonzalez on a very cheap MLB contract or a minor league deal with opt outs. I know we have utility guys, bringing in a veteran to compete with them is something I would like to do personally.
 
Also @CATS44 @Gson @CDAV45

Once things get back to being open, who are your free agent targets?...

First off I still think my first target would be LHP Andrew Chafin...

Next it would be bringing in the Shaw, Parker's of the world. Tomlin, Kintzler, Joe Smith, Andrew Miller etc... best talent possible for minor league deal with invites to the major league club and opt outs.. Duffy is another guy I think I would get into camp and have incentives, mid season opt out and whatnot. I want to bring in as many good veterans as possible who have good leadership abilities. We are a really young team so adding experience in my mind is a must...

Next on the docket... catchers... In free agency not much there, but bringing in someone like Greiner i think is necessary at the end of the day...

Next on my list of course is spending Blitzer's money on Bryant... if that does work then Suzuki... if that doesn't work then realistically...I am thinking Andrew McCutchen... or Michael Conforto to man our LF... plus then bring in a guy like Locastro on a minor league deal (he's likely out until July/Aug). Also maybe see if we can get a Marwin Gonzalez on a very cheap MLB contract or a minor league deal with opt outs. I know we have utility guys, bringing in a veteran to compete with them is something I would like to do personally.
I'm going to piece meal this together a little bit..

First name that came to mind.. was Chris Valaika.. who has he been with/was successful with/failed with..that is still playing and still has what may be a very limited chance to become a success. One name comes to mind.. Lewis Brinson.. He's hugely athletic.. doesn't walk much at all.. K's more than you'd like.. but Valaika and this guy have crossed paths.. they know each other and or they know of each other.. Does Valaika have a golden touch that he can unlock whatever ails this Brinson?.. He'd be an NRI for the Guardians.. but.

Billy McKinney is another name that comes to mind.. another NRI.. Does Valaika and Billy have the chance to work together to put the best of billy on the field?.. IDK.. but..

I'll get away from these "long shots".. and look at more than just OF'ers...
 
Aside from named Free Agents.. which will be continued..

...there are no Blitzer buck$$... at least.. not yet.. perhaps in the run up to the start of the 2023 season we'll see some influence of the new minority owner.. but..
 

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Video

Episode 3-13: "Backup Bash Brothers"

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Spotify

Episode 3:11: "Clipping Bucks."
Top