No I'm using: would it have mattered if Kevin walked for the Cavs? Would they have been x amount worse the last few seasons w/o Love on the roster?
I'm also using the, "the Cavs knew his market pretty well since he'd been rumored in trade talks since 2014" angle. It's not that maybe Love would have signed for a reasonable amount, it's that the Cavs didn't really need him on a max deal, at least for max years.
They are probably stuck now, in most cases they'd have to include a more enticing piece to off load the deal. Best hope is for him to find his health and contribute, he's a better fit than Andre with this group, and the Cavs could use his shooting, but he's never on the floor.
I guess your point is Love was a former AS and the Cavs needed to pony up to keep him. I agree.
My point is I don't think they needed to actually keep him at terms that didn't work at least as far as number of years.
We have talked hoops for a long time and I'm not trying to strawman your point at all. As a poster you have a lot of respect in my book.
I bolded what I believe you put forth as your main thesis. Looks like you agree Love was worth $30 million a year at that time, but you felt the Cavs should have pushed hard for a three year deal instead of a 4 year contract, correct?
I can agree with you that the fourth year is completely in Love's benefit, not the Cavs... but I still think another team would have offered that fourth year, making it a moot point.
What people really hate about the Love contract was that the Cavs didn't get a full season out of him in that first age 29 season. That was the real value year of the contract and he went from dinged up to shelved in order to tank.
Last season was exactly what I expected from Love, just not what I expected from the league. In hindsight, it looks on the surface like Love didn't play much. It's important to remember he took some load management games before anybody could have imagined the COVID shutdown, and further who would have predicted the Cavs wouldn't be invited to finish the season?
The calf injury this season sucks. I'm hoping to see what this team can do when he is back. The team went from a playoff contestant to birdshit when Nance got hurt and Lamar Stephens became a vital part of the rotation at PF.
Love is set up to fit really well in about a week.