MLB Draft 2026

..disagree with ALL of this...

Catcher is not a need in this draft, but if your BPA is a catcher, you take the catcher... Though I am doubting they take one in day one in a sense...
 
@Tondo ..

...yes.. I do want those kinds of arms.. there's an old adage that says you can teach a kid to throw a curveball.. but you can't teach him to throw 98..

..You have to train them to get to that level.. most never make it..

..but in spite of your faith in Jeremy Sowers.. & with all the training in the world.. He was NEVER going to throw 95+..

The Cleveland Minor League system is bereft of high end SP potentials.. not completely empty.. but, who would you say below AA is going to be the "next" Big Rig?... This number of clubs salivating over the likes of Justin LeBron is going to allow real ML'ers to come to the Guards.. if they take advantage.. wet dream or not..
 
@Tondo ..

...yes.. I do want those kinds of arms.. there's an old adage that says you can teach a kid to throw a curveball.. but you can't teach him to throw 98..

..You have to train them to get to that level.. most never make it..

..but in spite of your faith in Jeremy Sowers.. & with all the training in the world.. He was NEVER going to throw 95+..

The Cleveland Minor League system is bereft of high end SP potentials.. not completely empty.. but, who would you say below AA is going to be the "next" Big Rig?... This number of clubs salivating over the likes of Justin LeBron is going to allow real ML'ers to come to the Guards.. if they take advantage.. wet dream or not..

They've wasted multiple millions on raw HS arms. If even this org can't develop them properly, maybe the ROI isn't worth it.

There's a fine line and there are enough HS arms out there who have a better foundation and still offer mid to upper 90s heat. I mentioned McCarthy who would be a 1st rd lock if he was 3 inches taller.
 

19. Guardians: Sawyer Strosnider, OF, Texas Christian (No. 22)
We continue to hear only hitters here, and there’d be interest in Condon or Grindlinger from the high school side, and a number of those aforementioned college bats as well. The Guardians would seriously consider adding Strosnider’s left-handed power to the mix


Strosnider is a mix of LaViolette and Curley, so I have real angst they like him. Hope he's off the board. If we take him and leave Flukey like in this mock, I'll be very disappointed

Pipeline has final Top 250 out, btw. They aren't good evaluaters, but they have a good beat who teams like, so their ranking, especially top 100 is essential info
 
They’ll draft a HS pitcher or SS with their first pick.

They just can’t help themselves…
 

19. Guardians: Sawyer Strosnider, OF, Texas Christian (No. 22)
We continue to hear only hitters here, and there’d be interest in Condon or Grindlinger from the high school side, and a number of those aforementioned college bats as well. The Guardians would seriously consider adding Strosnider’s left-handed power to the mix


Strosnider is a mix of LaViolette and Curley, so I have real angst they like him. Hope he's off the board. If we take him and leave Flukey like in this mock, I'll be very disappointed

Pipeline has final Top 250 out, btw. They aren't good evaluaters, but they have a good beat who teams like, so their ranking, especially top 100 is essential info
I couldn't hate this pick more. There is zero chance a name like Sawyer Strosnider becomes a star bigleaguer. I could only get behind this if he agrees to a name change upon drafting, to something like Hank Strongman, Magnus ver Fellerson, or Zap McGwire. Edit: same goes for that guy named 'Fluky'.
 
Arms like Bumila, Sims or Putnam are just too raw and projection for my taste. No more raw mid/up 90s HS arms with little else, please. Draft pitchers, not throwers.

If you want an high octane HS arm, Kaiden McCarthy is my guy
Or how about another Canadian arm LHP Sean Duncan with Will Hynes looking good.

Flukey and Advincula would be a wet dream scenario but both will likely be long gone by picks 19 and 59.

I'd be ok gambling on Brick at 95, but not a fan of his profile, tbh. Too much projection here too in a deep college C class. Id tap into that pool and leave the HS C altogether.

Comeau is a HS bat I like and can't get away from. Also was very impressed with Combine showing of cINFs Jack Beck and Michael Autrey (easy 70 power) and quick hitterish look of MIF CJ Weinstein.
Have no real opinion on Landon Thome. His profile reads ok and it would be fun to have him in the system, but no real feel for him.

Although it's usually a demographic I advocated to stay away from, I am intrigued by this year's HS 1B class. Santarelli, Adams, Bland in particular. Overall, 1B class is very strong. I've been high on Caden Ferraro as mid round darling, but it looks like that cat is out of the bag after he wowed at combine and he'll go top 100 like Levu.
AJ Evasco is my new mid round high upside hope, but there are many more that offer value later (K. Lewis, Ballinger, Paulsen, K. Schmitt)

Ideally, day one starts and ends with college arms Flukey and Marohn (or DeCaro or E. Norby) with 2 HS upside plays in rounds 2 and 3

I suspect CLE will be all over the young but raw HS profiles like Grindlinger, Maniscalco, T. Ebel.

Adding another comp B pick in that 70 range would be huge to bolster this draft class. Kwan or Bo for one of those...
I could see Bo as part of a deal where he ends up as a NYY.. thereby allowing the NYY's to sort of stick it to Josh.... Yankees & that zoo in the RF bleachers have a LOOOOOONNNNGGGGGG memory...
 
Brody Bumila has just found out he has an UCL injury that may require TJ surgery. He’s already had the brace procedure in 2025 on the same elbow. He is now a lock for the Guardians to take at #19 after finding out this news.
 
In all seriousness I feel for the kid. Literally lost 6-7 figures with the news… will probably head to Texas now and sit out next season rehabbing. Would never wish that on anyone, especially a teenage kid. But selfishly I’m glad his unfortunate situation takes the temptation in taking the 6’10 lefty off the table as an option now for the Guards.
 
In all seriousness I feel for the kid. Literally lost 6-7 figures with the news… will probably head to Texas now and sit out next season rehabbing. Would never wish that on anyone, especially a teenage kid. But selfishly I’m glad his unfortunate situation takes the temptation in taking the 6’10 lefty off the table as an option now for the Guards.

This organization wouldn't be afraid to essentially throw a day three pick at him to see if he signs... They would be able to control everything about his training... Would I draft him early... No...
 
This organization wouldn't be afraid to essentially throw a day three pick at him to see if he signs... They would be able to control everything about his training... Would I draft him early... No...
Would make sense for the Guardians but why would you sign if you were the player going on day 3 when you can go to college for free to rehab, possibly earn some NIL in the process, and rehab your elbow the next 3 seasons to put yourself in a better draft position?
 
Would make sense for the Guardians but why would you sign if you were the player going on day 3 when you can go to college for free to rehab, possibly earn some NIL in the process, and rehab your elbow the next 3 seasons to put yourself in a better draft position?

Will the College have better care for his injury than the Guardians? Plus who would be better at developing him after he comes back from said injury? He may actually earn more money in the end if he ends up with the one who can help his development the best...
 
Would make sense for the Guardians but why would you sign if you were the player going on day 3 when you can go to college for free to rehab, possibly earn some NIL in the process, and rehab your elbow the next 3 seasons to put yourself in a better draft position?
What's the NIL landscape for baseball players? I'd have to imagine a lot less than basketball/football.
 
Back
Top