NFL Playoffs

Do Not Sell My Personal Information

BimboColesHair

I'd rather be golfing.
Joined
Dec 31, 2011
Messages
17,804
Reaction score
31,759
Points
148
I'm seeing alot of tweets about how wins is not a qb stat because of Jimmy G moving on.

But then I look at Jameis and the Bucs losing because of his 30 interceptions and how they got Brady and instantly became a winner...

Idk

QB play obviously gets the job done. Very seldom do you have a Trent Dilfer/Jimmy G situation.

QB W/L record only recently became a thing because mouth breathing troglodytes like Skip Bayless and Colin Cowherd and Stephen A Smith and the rest of the 24/7 sports news cycle have fetishized ring culture as the only meaningful thing to judge players by and, unfortunately, a good portion of sports fans have started behaving that way too when discussing various players or how they root for their favorite teams.
 

cavsfever

All-Star
Joined
Nov 23, 2005
Messages
8,301
Reaction score
9,704
Points
113
If you watched the game though Garoppolo made some real clutch passes in the 4th. Compare his final drive to Rogers. It’s obviously not that he’s better than Rogers, but the Niners designed good plays for him and he stayed within himself and just executed.
 

KevinLoveFan

My username is cool again.
Joined
Jan 7, 2018
Messages
973
Reaction score
1,435
Points
93
QB W/L record only recently became a thing because mouth breathing troglodytes like Skip Bayless and Colin Cowherd and Stephen A Smith and the rest of the 24/7 sports news cycle have fetishized ring culture as the only meaningful thing to judge players by and, unfortunately, a good portion of sports fans have started behaving that way too when discussing various players or how they root for their favorite teams.
I remember you are a Vikings guy. Would you take Qirk over Jimmy G? Qirk has his faults -- too conservative/underthrows in clutch moments, has mobility but prefers to take sacks in the pocket, etc. -- but from what I've seen, he's nonetheless a more skilled QB than G. G may look like Tyrone Power, but every time I watch a 49ers game, he sucks, so I don't care how hot he is, he always disappoints. Last one I watched, it was all about Deebo Samuel, not G. And I definitely remember the underperformance against the Chiefs in the SB (Chiefs are the other NFL team I follow a fair amount besides the Vikings; I live in Springfield MO, so it's a city requirement to like the MO team here).
 

Dr. Claw

Loves Cold, Hates Heat
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
3,046
Reaction score
2,890
Points
113
Trey Lance to Cleveland confirmed.
I'm down with that.
Jimmy G is the kind of QB that used to be on the Ravens prior to Joe Flacco (and some might even say including Flacco). I'm talking Dilfer, Grbac, BoLOLer level.
Luckily for the 49ers, their defense is 2000s Ratbird Approved.

Hopefully Rams handle business tomorrow. I don't want Jimmy G being responsible for keeping the LOAT out of the Super Bowl.
 

Hurl Bruce

Logmaster
Joined
Apr 21, 2005
Messages
11,224
Reaction score
16,410
Points
123
Is Davante Adams a FA this year as well? Could both Adams and Rodgers worm their way out of town?
 

BimboColesHair

I'd rather be golfing.
Joined
Dec 31, 2011
Messages
17,804
Reaction score
31,759
Points
148
I remember you are a Vikings guy. Would you take Qirk over Jimmy G? Qirk has his faults -- too conservative/underthrows in clutch moments, has mobility but prefers to take sacks in the pocket, etc. -- but from what I've seen, he's nonetheless a more skilled QB than G. G may look like Tyrone Power, but every time I watch a 49ers game, he sucks, so I don't care how hot he is, he always disappoints. Last one I watched, it was all about Deebo Samuel, not G. And I definitely remember the underperformance against the Chiefs in the SB (Chiefs are the other NFL team I follow a fair amount besides the Vikings; I live in Springfield MO, so it's a city requirement to like the MO team here).

Kirk has proven over multiple years he is a better QB than Jimmy G, so of course I take him over Jimmy.

Kirk’s problem is the Vikings defense sucks and has for 3 straight seasons, their line is as easy to get through as Piper Perri on a Brazzers set and has been for a decade plus, so maybe more like Lisa Ann on a Brazzers set, and based on what we’ve heard recently with the firings, his coach was no longer a good fit for the locker room.

W/L is still a team stat, down to the coaching. The Vikings fans that say “Kirk isn’t a winner” are the worst. Their team as a whole has been dog shit outside of QB, RB, WR 1 & 2, FS, and MLB the last 3 years.
 

Dr. Claw

Loves Cold, Hates Heat
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
3,046
Reaction score
2,890
Points
113
Kirk has proven over multiple years he is a better QB than Jimmy G, so of course I take him over Jimmy.

Kirk’s problem is the Vikings defense sucks and has for 3 straight seasons, their line is as easy to get through as Piper Perri on a Brazzers set and has been for a decade plus, so maybe more like Lisa Ann on a Brazzers set, and based on what we’ve heard recently with the firings, his coach was no longer a good fit for the locker room.

W/L is still a team stat, down to the coaching. The Vikings fans that say “Kirk isn’t a winner” are the worst. Their team as a whole has been dog shit outside of QB, RB, WR 1 & 2, FS, and MLB the last 3 years.
Facts. Kirk is quietly one of the most efficient QBs relative to his stats but... the defense is especially ass. It helps that most of their offensive skill players are very good. Stefon Diggs left there and they still can score.

Jimmy G is basically "Ravens" grade QB prior to Flacco (and some might even say including Flacco). I mean Dilfer, Grbac, and BoLOLer level. If the Niners defense wasn't what it was, they get washed by the Cowboys.
 

Lee

Gold Star Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2005
Messages
33,179
Reaction score
46,167
Points
148
I'm down with that.
Jimmy G is the kind of QB that used to be on the Ravens prior to Joe Flacco (and some might even say including Flacco). I'm talking Dilfer, Grbac, BoLOLer level.
Luckily for the 49ers, their defense is 2000s Ratbird Approved.

Hopefully Rams handle business tomorrow. I don't want Jimmy G being responsible for keeping the LOAT out of the Super Bowl.

How did you not include Flacco automatically in that list?
 

PIP

(.)(.)
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Apr 21, 2005
Messages
11,958
Reaction score
33,387
Points
148
Aaron Fraudgers is such a good trend right now…

 

Help For Business Hit By Covid

Total amount
$1,170.00
Goal
$1,000.00

Rubber Rim Job Podcast

Episode 1:6 "Follow the DG Leader"
Top