Opinions on threads in Minor league forum?

[sportscoach]

Alright, I am trying to ask some questions and figure out what type of threads we want in this minor league... it's not letting me do a poll, but I was thinking, do we want individual threads for each level of play? For individual prospects? We will have weekly game threads and a discussion game thread as well, I just want to see what everyone else thinks we need in here... @MadThinker88 any ideas as well?

@Sebastian is making polls still available in these forums? I couldn't find anything anywhere lol

 

[sportscoach]

I was thinking of starting AAA talk 22, AA Talk 22, A ball Talk 22 and Rookie ball talk 22 type of things. We would still have the general talk, Then maybe if we wanted we could start threads on individual players and/or something that has top prospects thread type of thing. We don't have to and can keep things currently the same. I am just curious what everyone thinks...

@Gson @CDAV45 @Criznit @petes999 etc.

 

[daddywags]

As someone who doesn't know who's who in our minor leagues very well I would prefer each class have it own thread. That would make it easier for me to keep the players straight.

 

[sportscoach]

As someone who doesn't know who's who in our minor leagues very well I would prefer each class have it own thread. That would make it easier for me to keep the players straight.

Would you like roster updates now and again as well? The rosters down there do get moved around a lot

Would you like a prospect thread/threads for individual top prospects?

 

[MadThinker88]

Unless someone is going to dedicate a bunch of time to the details, we want to be careful how much items get divided down.

Overall weekly game threads make sense...
Individual threads for each level of team (a AAA thread, a AA thread, a high A thread, & a Low A thread, a thread for the Arizona Complez & another thread for DSL) also makes sense...

Individual prospect threads I believe goes to far especially as some conversations will cross-pollinate (was the remark in the Arias thread or the Rocchio thread or the Tena thread or the Tyler Freeman thread)...

 

[sportscoach]

Unless someone is going to dedicate a bunch of time to the details, we want to be careful how much items get divided down.

Overall weekly game threads make sense...
Individual threads for each level of team (a AAA thread, a AA thread, a high A thread, & a Low A thread, a thread for the Arizona Complez & another thread for DSL) also makes sense...

Individual prospect threads I believe goes to far especially as some conversations will cross-pollinate (was the remark in the Arias thread or the Rocchio thread or the Tena thread or the Tyler Freeman thread)...

Then make a prospect thread talk thread or just leave that in regular minor league talk?

 

[MadThinker88]

Then make a prospect thread talk thread or just leave that in regular minor league talk?

I dont think a separate thread is needed for the prospect talk..
That generally gets covered in the various team/ level threads...

 

[Criznit]

Definitely need AAA and AA in separate threads. If you want to combine A ball, not ideal, but works - add in everything else wherever it fits.

 

[daddywags]

Would you like roster updates now and again as well? The rosters down there do get moved around a lot

Would you like a prospect thread/threads for individual top prospects?

I imagine promotions/demotions would be covered in each class thread (i.e., so-and-so has been promoted to Akron). I think prospect threads would be too much. I'd prefer to get all Columbus news in one thread, Akron news in another, etc. Thanks for asking!

 

[LL3]

I was thinking of starting AAA talk 22, AA Talk 22, A ball Talk 22 and Rookie ball talk 22 type of things. We would still have the general talk, Then maybe if we wanted we could start threads on individual players and/or something that has top prospects thread type of thing. We don't have to and can keep things currently the same. I am just curious what everyone thinks...

@Gson @CDAV45 @Criznit @petes999 etc.

Yeah, a thread for each farm team etc seems good...I'd like it anyway.