The Clase/Ortiz Gambling Scandal

The Human Q-Tip

Alright you primitive screwheads, listen up!
Staff member
Administrator
Joined
Jul 15, 2008
Messages
38,956
Reaction score
78,089
Points
148
Okay, this is the thread where anyone who wants to discuss the topic should feel free to do so. Do not come in here to discuss this issue, and then try to silence those with a different point of view just because you don't want to hear their arguments anymore.

As always, personal attacks are a no-no. Attack the post, not the poster.
 
Good Idea on new thread.

That kind of cuts both ways. On the one hand, you'd think that they wouldn't suspend them unless they were more or less certain. But on the other, would you really continue to roll guys out there as long as there is at least a reasonable basis to believe they were corrupt?

It is hard to tell, For the other mlb gambling last year (with 4 guys), there was little to no lead up investigation (probably just talked with them). The betting watchdog just gave them the 4 names and next day (or something), they were banned. Now, there was a clear paper trail, thus there was no accessing computers or anything to figure out. Kelly pitched on June 1 and on June 4th was banned (he is now pitching again).

Ohtani is Ohtani but MLB didn't even really look into the false statement that Ohtani paid off the gamblers willingly by his interpreter and spokesperson at first. Nor, the subsequent correction the next day to say he had no knowledge to avoid linking him to the case. He opened the season 2 days later.

The only lengthy investigation (from Feb to May 2024) was on Umpire Hoberg and that was because betting on baseball came from his gambling account and thus he had knowledge of what was going on for 2 years and how it would look (morality clause of not harming the game). He was under investigation since February 2024 and was disciplined on June 14th (held out of games during that time) with a lifetime ban due to "His extremely poor judgment in sharing betting accounts with a professional poker player he had reason to believe bet on baseball and who did, in fact, bet on baseball from the shared accounts, combined with his deletion of messages, creates at minimum the appearance of impropriety that warrants imposing the most severe discipline."

As to what to expect from Ortiz and Clase, I hope it is more than just a casual association (have text or confession from bettors on how info and what info was obtained). For Hoberg, he did not get immediately fired even though bets came from HIS account (as he created a plausible excuse of his gambling buddy). Now, the excuse probably was deemed "illegal" (it would have avoided IRS tax rules on winning bets given credit to wrong person) and with deleting text, it can fall more into that Commish purview and he did give a lifetime ban. But, if there was a 100% paper trail (like the 4 players) and no denial it was done, the punishment would have already been doled out in matter of days like the 4. There was no further investigation needed (to see if they used other accounts) to create a case. They may have looked further afterwards to see if a longer punishment was needed.

Now what they may have on Ortiz and Clase is anyone's guess. But, note younger players would be more tempted to text only and may use more app-deleting measures (like SnapChat) than an aging umpire. But, if they were stupid enough to be linked to this, they may not have known how to cover their tracks completely.
 
Last edited:
Good Idea on new thread.



It is hard to tell, For the other mlb gambling last year (with 4 guys), there was no lead up investigation. The betting watchdog just gave them the 4 names and next day (or something), they were banned. Now, there was a clear paper trail, thus there was no accessing computers or anything to figure out. Kelly pitched on June 1 and on June 4th was banned (he is now pitching again). They did not investigate like Hoberg to figure out who made the bets. But, no one appealed the suspensions (so deemed clear cut).

Ohtani is Ohtani but MLB didn't even really look into the false statement that Ohtani paid off the gamblers willingly by his interpreter and spokesperson at first. Nor, the subsequent correction the next day to say he had no knowledge to avoid linking him to the case. He opened the season 2 days later.

The only lengthy investigation (from Feb to May 2024) was on Umpire Hoberg and that was because betting on baseball came from his gambling account and thus he had knowledge of what was going on for 2 years and how it would look (morality clause of not harming the game). He was under investigation since February 2024 and was disciplined on June 14th (held out of games during that time) with a lifetime ban due to "His extremely poor judgment in sharing betting accounts with a professional poker player he had reason to believe bet on baseball and who did, in fact, bet on baseball from the shared accounts, combined with his deletion of messages, creates at minimum the appearance of impropriety that warrants imposing the most severe discipline."

As to what to expect from Ortiz and Clase, I hope it is more than just a casual association (have text or confession from bettors on how info and what info was obtained). For Hoberg, he did not get immediately fired even though bets came from HIS account (as he created a plausible excuse of his gambling buddy). Now, the excuse probably was deemed "illegal" (it would have avoided IRS tax rules on winning bets given credit to wrong person) and with deleting text, it can fall more into that Commish purview and he did give a lifetime ban. But, if there was a 100% paper trail (like the 4 players) and no denial it was done, the punishment would have already been doled out in matter of days like the 4. There was no further investigation needed (to see if they used other accounts) to create a case. They may have looked further afterwards to see if a longer punishment was needed.

Now what they may have on Ortiz and Clase is anyone's guess. But, note younger players would be more tempted to text only and may use more app-deleting measures (like SnapChat) than an aging umpire. But, if they were stupid enough to be linked to this, they may not have known how to cover their tracks completely.

I am guessing this is as good of place as any, do you (and others) believe Ohtani was innocent like MLB said, do you think it was his bets? Had a fall guy take one for the team for him?

Personally I dont believe he was innocent, but baseball is in a tough place. They banned the hit leader for life, and now only letting him into the hall possibly after his death, but Ohtani escaped penalty free because baseball is now in bed with gambling via advertisements.
 
Now for those who may come here and look for a timeline or historical info.
Ortiz - 2nd inning at Seattle (to Arozarena) on June 15 and 3rd inning vs St Louis at home (to Pages) on June 27th
Clase - no clue on who was involved but clip of 11 bad pitches. Shows much worse control on 0-0 pitches than in 2024 but similar to 2023 (and 1-1 pitches in 2025 are not much better on control).

The bulletin pasted in each clubhouse and reviewed (condensed version says
I. Prohibited Conduct for Major League Players
A. No Betting on Baseball. Major League Players may not bet (nor ask others to bet on their behalf or receive benefits from other bets or assist bets from others) on any professional or amateur baseball games (including, without limitation, Major League Baseball, Minor League Baseball, international, college, high school and youth games) (hereinafter referred to as “Baseball Games”) or events (including, without limitation, home run derbies, all-star games, skills competitions and tournaments) (hereinafter referred to as “Baseball Events”). This prohibition applies to all bets related to Baseball Games or Baseball Events, including, without limitation, bets on the outcome of games (either individual games or multiple games such as a series or season) or events within games (e.g., the outcome of a particular pitch, atbat, play or inning), any all-star game or home run derby, postseason qualification or results, the performance of players, actions that take place during games, transactions or the draft. See also Major League Rule 21(d).

B. Fantasy Games. Major League Players are prohibited from knowingly engaging in any of the following conduct with respect to full-season, partial season, or daily fantasy baseball games (including, but not limited to, online fantasy baseball games from providers such as Fan Duel, Draft Kings, and other similar entities) (collectively, “Fantasy Baseball Games”):....

C. Illegal Betting. Major League Players may not place illegal bets on any sport or event, including bets placed with illegal bookmakers or illegal offshore sports betting websites or applications. See Major League Rule 21(d)(3).

D. Betting on Sports Other Than Baseball. Major League Players may place legal bets on sporting events other than Baseball Games and Baseball Events in jurisdictions in which such bets are legal, provided that the person placing the bet is eligible under applicable law to place the wager.

E. Game Fixing. Major League Players are prohibited from intentionally influencing or manipulating (or intentionally attempting to influence or manipulate) any Baseball Game or Baseball Event so that the final outcome, or any other outcome or aspect of the game or event, is fully determined by anything other than its merits. A Major League Player also violates this rule if, upon being solicited by any person or entity to engage in such behavior, the Player fails to inform the Commissioner immediately of the solicitation, and of all facts and circumstances connected therewith. See also Major League Rule 21(a).

F. No Tipping or Disclosure of Confidential Information. Confidential information, including non-public information regarding player health, rosters, lineups, transactions, discipline or umpires, may be sought by individuals who desire to exploit such information in the betting markets. Major League Players are prohibited from intentionally disclosing such confidential information regarding their Clubs, their Club’s Minor League affiliates or MLB, or any professional or amateur baseball team or league, to any person with the knowledge that that person intends to use such confidential information in connection with the betting markets.
 
I am guessing this is as good of place as any, do you (and others) believe Ohtani was innocent like MLB said, do you think it was his bets? Had a fall guy take one for the team for him?

Personally I dont believe he was innocent, but baseball is in a tough place. They banned the hit leader for life, and now only letting him into the hall possibly after his death, but Ohtani escaped penalty free because baseball is now in bed with gambling via advertisements.

I go back and forth because if it is a clear cut violation (aided someone with winning a bet on your game), that is a LIFETIME ban, no exceptions, no more proof gathering needed and that MLB has the proof (testimony and/or text and/or wire transfers) in hand and punishment would have been swift (like the 4 players). Why keep a story alive more than you have to when it hurts your brand?

Now, I think they talked to Clase and Ortiz and asked for their side of the story. They must have not admitted to it and MLB doesn't have all the info yet (to hold up in their arbitration - clear cut) or the provided an alternate scenario (like Hoberg). Now, the MLB is investigating it further expecting an arbitration.

I just don't like the instant found guilty by just saying it is abnormal bet = win = friend or acquaintance to Ortiz/Clase = guilt. I came up with number of different scenarios that someone my bet on an Ortiz/Clase pitch and win a few in a row. Including drinking with them heavily the night before thus knowing it would be a bad game. Kind of wondering if this is a Dominican gambling scheme where they just hit them up first with threats back home. But, that is also a violation on not reporting such acts immediately.

Based on the rules as written, they need to prove "knowingly" -- get some link between the bettor and Ortiz and communications were kept or were abnormal linked to those days in particular (not a daily conversation). And, one of my other theories was the game planning on how to attack certain hitters. A friend may have just looked at his team's iPad that was sitting out or he could have casually asked about hitter X and if he feared him (and say ... no he chases or we are throwing him sliders today). If he didn't intentionally give someone he knew that would use the information to make bets, it is a gray area.

I tried to show in the main thread how their 0-0 pitchers are not that different from 1-1 pitches other than maybe 1-2 pitches that MLB thinks it has but it isn't statistical proof. If you look at the illustrator of his last Cardinals game there would be 8-12 non-competitive pitches (was he wild on purpose or did the better guess right). He did go 6 innings but gave up 4 runs.


In Seattle, he let in 6 runs, thus not his best game either. Again on purpose or just an off night that even if he went 6 innings it wasn't spotting his pitches. If I was Ortiz, I would ask MLB why there isn't bets on 4th or 21st which were better games? Why just these 2?


And I said early on. MLB needs to go back and look at game plans and talk to Bo/Hedgie to see if he shook off their pitch type or location. It isn't a slam dunk. And, the decision to fire Hoberg wasn't made to end of May even after being investigated for at least 3 months even though he knew illegal bets (based on another person) were being made from his account (thus penalty up to Commish even though he supposedly didn't bet himself but couldn't prove it due to deleted messages).
 
Last edited:
My guess is this has been going on for a bit, and whoever these betting outlets are were not about to let this continue (so the MLB agreed).
 
Only raised 12k or something silly low like that.

But yeah, not a good look that an established major leaguer would want to do an income sharing plan.
When he did the financial deal, it was well before he was "established" in the league.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lee
I am guessing this is as good of place as any, do you (and others) believe Ohtani was innocent like MLB said, do you think it was his bets? Had a fall guy take one for the team for him?

Personally I dont believe he was innocent, but baseball is in a tough place. They banned the hit leader for life, and now only letting him into the hall possibly after his death, but Ohtani escaped penalty free because baseball is now in bed with gambling via advertisements.
They banned Pete after he had finished playing.

Banning Ohtani, a top 3 current player who MLB draws tremendous revenue from domestically and internationally, would have merited a black and white, open and shut case and most likely months to year long investigation w/ paid suspension. Would the paid suspension be currently paid money only, or include the deferred amount? Perhaps MLB didn't want to look too far in that rabbit hole and uncover what else was laid hidden from public view. Or maybe Ohtani was innocent and too trusting. Who knows?
 
Only raised 12k or something silly low like that.

But yeah, not a good look that an established major leaguer would want to do an income sharing plan.
I think NIL money for US-born athletes killed what could have been a promising, boom/bust penny stock-like industry. Maybe the young international signings if signed when they are 16/17 still have a market.
 
Back
Top