- Joined
- Jul 15, 2008
- Messages
- 34,295
- Reaction score
- 65,103
- Points
- 148
Why are so many people assuming they don't fit together?? Their skill sets are not THAT similar. Dion can drive and kick or pull up. Kyrie can spot up and finish at the rim.
You can stick them both on the court and "force" them to get along, but it's certainly not an ideal fit. I'd say it is three things. The first is that because our bigs cannot spread the floor, the paint is often so crowded that it is difficult to penetrate and finish. Kyrie is exceptional at finishing, so it is not much of a problem for him. But for Dion, it takes a weakness and makes it worse. That means he needs to be more of an off-ball, spot-up guy like Miles, and that's not really his game.
The second is that both of them like to bring the ball up, initiate the offense, and sometimes pound the ball and run iso's. But there's only one ball, and it seems inevitable -- to me at least -- that the guy without the ball isn't going to like that much. I understand the concept of forcing them to change their games and each give up some control of the ball, but that's essentially asking both of them to change the way they've always played. If either one -- much less both -- of them don't fully buy into that, that's a real problem. Honestly, I think both of them want the other to be the spot-up guy.
And the third is that Dion is not good at moving off the ball, and that is essential when Kyrie is the guy initiating the offense. He kind of just stands there, and I think it's because it's a role he's never really played before -- he's used to having the ball in his hands. Kyrie is better at it, but to take advantage of that, you'd essentially have to make Dion more the PG, and Kyrie the SG. And that is not something Kyrie wants -- he wants the ball in his hands as the PG.
What you really want is for their games to be synergistic -- that each of them actually makes the other better because their games naturally mesh. And they just don't. As others have said, you can try to "force" that, but that's pretty much admitting that their games do not mesh naturally. They may mesh in theory -- "if only they would learn to....", but that's never been who either of these guys are. Not in terms of skills, but in terms of the roles they've played their whole careers.