I'm expecting Feller, Doby, Thome, and Vizquel will be the ones selected tonight.
I think Thome and Vizquel are both great, Hall of Fame-worthy players. There's just a few things I can't get past:
1) The way Thome left. I know most don't blame him, but I think he handled it terribly. I don't want to get into this for the 392593834th time, but I'll just say I'm not over it.
2) In 232 career postseason at-bats, Thome hit .211. He had his moments, but he mostly struggled when it mattered most.
3) Omar is a borderline Hall of Famer, and although he's my favorite player of all-time and a guy I think will and should get in, I can't argue that he's Top 4 All-Time with the Tribe.