Maybe if it were asked by someone who did anything other than troll on thIs board?
Probably wasn't a serious question, and any conversation with Jigo rarely turns into anything relevant. I'll choose to brush of his question.
I thought ACab was an all-star defensive shortstop, Hannahan is a guy you play for defense, not his bat, and Kotchman is another defensive starter. If you're going to sacrifice offense for defense, shouldn't you at least be able to play defense?
Not that we actually have any offensive players that could be better, but still.