2012 Series #33 @ Twins -|- July 27th, 28th, and 29th.

[Pyro]

Gas Can Sipp just throwing everything away.

 

[SOA]

Had nothing to do with Willingham's injury history, now you're simply making things up.

no thats was reported i wouldn't make it up

twins offered 3 tribe wasn't willing to go beyond two due to injury concerns . . .I 'll let you enjoy the joy of Google to find it yourself

 

[AZ_]

no thats was reported i wouldn't make it up

twins offered 3 tribe wasn't willing to go beyond two due to injury concerns . . .I 'll let you enjoy the joy of Google to find it yourself

No, that is not what was reported.

Willingham had never been on the disabled list prior to this season.

The Indians felt his bat was a good fit, but that he is a defensive liability. Straight from Shapiro's twitter....

Stop making things up, maybe you should do a little more research with the joys of Google before you talk.

 

[SOA]

any we have Damon and Duncan playing playing left . . . brilliant

 

[SOA]

no need to change the arguement just responding to your lame search

 

[AZ_]

You mean the one that proved your nonsense wrong?

Maybe you should make up more counter arguments, as if there isn't enough to find wrong with this team....now you have to lie about it to try and prove some irrelevant point?

Move on...

 

[SOA]

• 
  [*=center]
  • 
    [*=center]http://www.sbnation.com/mlb/players/430/josh-willingham
  
  [*=center]

  	May 7, 2012
  	Facial injury, day-to-day
  	July 7, 2011
  	Missed 17 games (achilles)
  	June 23, 2011
  	Achilles, 15-day DL (retroactive to June 18)
  	June 6, 2011
  	Missed 1 game (left Achilles)
  	June 5, 2011
  	Left Achilles, day-to-day
  	April 29, 2011
  	Missed 2 games (back injury)
  	April 26, 2011
  	Back injury, day-to-day
  	November 11, 2010
  	Missed the last 44 games of the regular season (knee surgery)
  	September 3, 2010
  	Transferred from the 15-day DL to the 60-day DL (knee surgery)
  	August 19, 2010
  	Left knee injury, early September
  	August 17, 2010
  	Left knee injury, day-to-day
  	June 9, 2009
  	Missed 6 games (viral infection)
  	June 4, 2009
  	Viral infection, day-to-day
  	June 24, 2008
  	Missed 50 games (back injury)
  	May 2, 2008
  	Back injury, 15-day DL
  	May 1, 2008
  	Back injury, day-to-day
  	October 1, 2007
  	Missed the last 8 games of the regular season (back injury)
  	September 25, 2007
  	Back injury, day-to-day
  	September 18, 2007
  	Missed 2 games (back injury)
  	September 17, 2007
  	Back injury, day-to-day
  	August 9, 2007
  	Missed 3 games (kidney)
  	August 7, 2007
  	Kidney stones, day-to-day
  	June 21, 2006
  	Missed 12 games (hand injury)
  	June 14, 2006
  	Hand injury, 15-day DL
  	June 7, 2006
  	Back injury, day-to-day
  	September 2, 2005
  	Missed 52 games (forearm injury)
  	July 6, 2005
  	Forearm injury, 15-day DL

  
  <tbody>
  </tbody>

 

[AZ_]

Nice photo of Willingham, he's still never been to the DL....

 

[Stark]

A defensive liability?

We have Damon and Duncan out in left... you can't get a whole lot worse than that.

 

[3 Ball...GOT IT]

I can't watch any more Twins v Tribe games. It just pisses me off so much we let them have Willingham.

 

[AZ_]

A defensive liability?

We have Damon and Duncan out in left... you can't get a whole lot worse than that.

The plan, at the time, was Brantley in left field. Damon was an afterthought.

 

[AZ_]

If you don't agree with b00bie your just a troll lol. I secretly think he's Shapiro

Being somewhat educated and a devout follower of baseball, not screaming at the top of my lungs like the drunken moron in the bleachers makes me Mark Shapiro, so be it.

Sorry that his facts were clearly wrong and I corrected him, but it doesn't take a Princeton graduate to see that he's never been on the DL prior to 2012.

 

[Juice is Loose]

Being somewhat educated and a devout follower of baseball, not screaming at the top of my lungs like the drunken moron in the bleachers makes me Mark Shapiro, so be it.

Sorry that his facts were clearly wrong and I corrected him, but it doesn't take a Princeton graduate to see that he's never been on the DL prior to 2012.

I'll back SOA up. A's Josh Willingham DL'd, Prospect Chris Carter Promoted - Baseball Nation A's Josh Willingham heads to disabled list with strained calf, Chris Carter called up | oaklandathletics.com: News

There's 2 links about the same injury when he was with Oakland.

 

[AZ_]

Ah, it does appear he made a quick DL stint.

Doesn't really change anything, as that injury was more than healed before he hit free agency and the Indians Team President pretty much came out and said it was his defense.

I mean, not sure how much more clear it could get.

 

[SOA]

its clear you said he was never on the DL and that wasn't the case

its not clear that his defense was solely the reason he wasn't given the 3rd year that the Twins supposedly

iam not wasting my time looking it up to continue the dialogue anyway as they will never admit they are wrong - i.e Willingham was NEVER on the DL