I said it the time and I will say it again, that is a cultural thing. Southern black mothers would use a switch on their kids to discipline them. It is only this generation that considers that against the parents rights.
In the end, AP showed remorse and understanding that is not how things are done. Breaking your kids arm and showing no remorse is next level.
Just gonna leave this here:
"Upon returning to Minnesota, the Mother of the child took him to the doctor to treat the injuries. The child suffered cuts and bruises to his ankles, buttocks, legs, scrotum, and hands. The injuries to his hands are the result of defensive wounds."
I'm sorry, but this is not a cultural thing. He beat the living shit out of his kid. This is not a guy lightly giving his kid a belting for doing something bad. This is a child abuse thing.
It is cultural, doesn't make it right, but it is cultural.
I have plenty of southern black friends out here that I talked to when this came up, its how they were disciplined.
It isn't. My grandma is white, made us pick our own switches, and would swat at our legs until their was blood. I grew up in NE Ohio.It is cultural, doesn't make it right, but it is cultural.
I have plenty of southern black friends out here that I talked to when this came up, its how they were disciplined.
It isn't. My grandma is white, made us pick our own switches, and would swat at our legs until their was blood. I grew up in NE Ohio.
Give me Tyreek.
Hitting a kid with a belt/switch is unnecessary. It’s learned behavior for sure. Like somebody probably wouldn’t do it unless somebody did it to them first. But as a parent with a kid who is pretty damn stubborn, I’ve never even been in that ballpark or seen other kids doing anything that I didn’t think could have been diffused with words and pulling (and I do mean physically lifting up and pulling) a kid out of a situation. I’ve literally picked my child up and walked him out of a room. I’ve grabbed my kids wrist and pulled it away from something. I’ve shouted at him (and explained I shouldn’t have afterwards bc it was a loss of control in the moment).
I’ve been able to largely handle my kid’s behavior through calm discussion of it with him during and after. And while I understand not every kid is the same and I’m by no means a perfect parent...
I’ve NEVER felt the need to hit him with something.
That’s making it about your own emotion and lack of control. That’s a lack of ability to communicate and teach a lesson. It’s abuse.
That said, if a person shows remorse and stops doing it that’s to be respected. Problem is, he didn’t. He still does it. So yeah...it’s a cultural thing, but so is dog fighting. And both are vile.
Fuck that.
You show me a bratty, entitled 9 year-old, and I’ll show you a child who wasn’t spanked enough as a kid.Is spanking abuse?
I just don’t think of anything like belt/spanking/switch as abuse. I think it’s correcting bad behavior and it isn’t necessarily the best way, but I don’t agree. Shrugs.
It isn't. My grandma is white, made us pick our own switches, and would swat at our legs until their was blood. I grew up in NE Ohio.
And frankly if someone believes force (within reason) is justified, why would they need to show remorse? That's their belief and they could actually be right. You absolutely can tell who walked all over their parents and they are typically pieces of shit.You show me a bratty, entitled 9 year-old, and I’ll show you a child who wasn’t spanked enough as a kid.
I’m kidding. Or am I kidding? I’m not sure.
Hitting a kid with a belt/switch is unnecessary. It’s learned behavior for sure. Like somebody probably wouldn’t do it unless somebody did it to them first. But as a parent with a kid who is pretty damn stubborn, I’ve never even been in that ballpark or seen other kids doing anything that I didn’t think could have been diffused with words and pulling (and I do mean physically lifting up and pulling) a kid out of a situation. I’ve literally picked my child up and walked him out of a room. I’ve grabbed my kids wrist and pulled it away from something. I’ve shouted at him (and explained I shouldn’t have afterwards bc it was a loss of control in the moment).
I’ve been able to largely handle my kid’s behavior through calm discussion of it with him during and after. And while I understand not every kid is the same and I’m by no means a perfect parent...
I’ve NEVER felt the need to hit him with something.
That’s making it about your own emotion and lack of control. That’s a lack of ability to communicate and teach a lesson. It’s abuse.
That said, if a person shows remorse and stops doing it that’s to be respected. Problem is, he didn’t. He still does it. So yeah...it’s a cultural thing, but so is dog fighting. And both are vile.
Fuck that.
Spanking isn't abuse.
Is it done too often? Sure.
Should it be a last resort? Absolutely.
I think in most cases you can get away with talking to your child. But there are those times when a spanking (not a beating) will actually do some good.
Communication and conversation is absolutely essential, though.