http://www.freep.com/article/20110529/COL08/105290546/Drew-Sharp-NCAA-won-t-unleash-full-wrath-Ohio-State?odyssey=tab|topnews|text|FRONTPAGE
Drew Sharp: NCAA won't unleash its full wrath on Ohio State
All those salivating in Ann Arbor and East Lansing about Ohio State getting punished by the high priests of hypocrisy (a.k.a. the NCAA punitive police) should do themselves a favor for the sake of their own emotional stability.
Stop using the serious USC sanctions as a barometer for what should happen to Ohio State.
There are no similarities between the two cases as it pertains to one extremely important variable in every NCAA investigation: the expectation of the institutions to self-report infractions because of the NCAA's limited investigative scope. The willingness of the investigated to fall on the sword and give the NCAA Committee on Infractions something in their program's official response to the allegations often determines how hard the NCAA swings the hammer.
Ohio State did that.
USC didn't.
The Trojans lost their appeal with the NCAA last week. No surprise. USC must sit out the bowl season for the 2011 campaign and endure a loss of 30 scholarships over the next three years. But what many don't realize is that the Trojans got hammered not for the sins committed, but rather how they responded once the transgressions were brought to their attention nearly five years earlier.
USC's own arrogance brought it down. Thumb through its formal response to the NCAA's Notice of Allegations last year and you'll find little accountability and even less contrition. The university basically dared the NCAA investigators to come after one of college football's marquee brands.
It's a mess in Columbus, worsening every day. There's no way that Jim Tressel should survive this scandal.
A former football player told the student newspaper, The Lantern, that "everybody was doing it" in reference to selling memorabilia for money and getting questionably sweet deals on cars. A car salesman told The Sporting News that he had several phone conversations with the athletic department's compliance officer regarding the NCAA legality of what's now become the Buckeye Motor Bureau. That's an accusation that directly contradicts the school's report to the Committee on Infractions.
It's only a matter of time before it's revealed that The Ohio State University lost its prefix after football players sold the "The" for a tire rotation on one of those special SUVs.
But there's an important point lost in the rush to bury the Buckeyes that bears repeating. Despite all appearances of decorum run amok, all the NCAA asks of its member institutions in these situations is to stay out in front of the matter. Don't obfuscate: Investigate. Admit you screwed up. Hit yourself over the head with the hammer first. Even those that overtly lie and cheat will still get leniency if they come across as forthright in their internal probe.
Ohio State's doing that.
USC didn't.
That's why the NCAA nailed the Trojans with the most severe major allegations allowable -- lack of institutional control and failure to monitor -- in its formal list of charges against USC. The Buckeyes avoided that double dilemma in its NOA last month.
The USC verdict is only relevant in how NOT to conduct yourself during a NCAA investigation.