- Stromile Swift (2000)
- Jay Williams (2002) (injury)
- Darko Milicic (2003)
- Emeka Okafor (2004)
- Michael Beasley (2008)
- Hasheem Thabeet (2009)
- Evan Turner (2010)
- Derrick Williams (2011)
- Michael Kidd-Gilchrist (2012)
- Jabari Parker (2014)
Marvin Williams (2005) has carved out a nice career for himself, but he was still never a star. Deron Williams and Chris Paul were the next two picks after Williams in 2005.
Tyson Chandler (2001), LaMarcus Aldridge (2006), Kevin Durant (2007), Victor Oladipo (2013), and D'Angelo Russell (2015) have all made all-star games, but only Durant is a generational type player (Aldridge was very, very good at his peak as well).
Jury is still out on Brandon Ingram (2016), Lonzo Ball (2017), Marvin Bagley (2018), and Ja Morant (2019). Ingram looks like a perennial all-star if he can stay healthy. Lonzo looks to be a rotation guy, not an all-star. The next three picks after Bagley were Doncic, Jaren Jackson, and Trae Young, so that pick was a bust unless he turns into a perennial all-star, which I don't see happening. Morant is the favorite for ROY this year and looks like a future star.
But still though, it's pretty weird that you can look back at pretty much the past 20 years of #2 picks, and really the only big time ballers that were there are KD and Aldridge.