Seth Partnow of The Athletic has a series of columns on the top 125 players in the NBA, ranked in tiers 1-5. He started with Tier 5. Seth will reveal the rest of the tiers as we go through the week.
Tier 1 is just seven players. Tier 2 consists of 12 players, Tier 3 is 21 players, etc.
Here is a comment about how he groups the players into tiers.
A final comment before getting to the list of players in Tier 5: As time goes by, what might be called my basketball system of values continues to evolve based on the NBA game changing in ways that favor different skill sets — and as I (sometimes repeatedly) learn hard lessons about what works.
For example, in the past, I’ve overrated the specialist. It is no longer enough to simply have a single elite NBA skill and be a high-level contributor without doing more. If one were to create a continuum of NBA wing play, you wouldn’t be too far wrong to have Duncan Robinson and Matisse Thybulle take up either end of the spectrum. Whether deep shooting or defense, these two certainly possess that single elite attribute.
Yet their deficiencies in other areas dramatically reduced their ability to impact (and in Robinson’s case, even get on the floor) in high-level playoff series. Instead, having a degree of versatility — the malleability to function in different lineups and against different styles of opposition — has increasingly become more important in the NBA. There is room on a contender’s roster for situational options — an extra big body to deploy against the Sixers or Bucks, a ball-hawking backup point guard in anticipation of facing the Warriors or Suns. But having a special club in the bag doesn’t mean it’s one you expect to swing often, and this list is about outlasting all 29 other teams, not just providing some defensive resistance against Steph Curry specifically.
The main effect of this is that bigs have taken a hit in my estimation relative to perimeter players and especially wings. I don’t totally subscribe to many of the notions around the evils of drop coverage, or that non-switchable bigs aren’t playable. But a player being exploitable himself without having a concurrent rock-paper-scissors advantage over another group of players borders on disqualifying him.....
If there is a player type I’m lower on than consensus, it is the moderate- or low-efficiency bucket getter who doesn’t bring much value in other areas. While more shot creation is not a bad thing, top teams generally need complementary skills much more. So if you wonder why players with modest counting stats such as Alex Caruso make the list over some others, this is the reason.
Two Cavaliers made the 41-man Tier 5 list; Love and Markkanen. Since it's a 30-team league with 150 starters, about 80% of the starters make one of the five tiers.
One Cav dropped off last year's Tier 5 list; Collin Sexton.
The interesting thing to me is his comment about specialists being overrated. He specifically mentioned the Sixers' Matisse Thybulle, a perimeter defense specialist who averaged 5.7 mpg in 25 minutes per game. Isaac Okoro falls into the same category.
"It is no longer enough to simply have a single elite NBA skill and be a high-level contributor without doing more."
If that is the case then Okoro's value to the Cavs is limited and they were pretty dumb to take him with the 5th overall pick.
The comment about bigs taking "a hit" is concerning since the Cavs have so many of them, but he specifically mentioned "non-switchable bigs", which doesn't include Mobley, Allen, and Markkanen.
Finally, there's "the moderate- or low-efficiency bucket getter who doesn’t bring much value in other areas. While more shot creation is not a bad thing, top teams generally need complementary skills much more."
IOW, a Collin Sexton type. While Sexton dropping out of Tier 5 may have been due to his barely playing last year, his role as a "moderate-efficiency shot creator who doesn't bring much value in other areas" reduces his value.
This makes me wonder if either Okoro or Sexton will have a significant role on the Cavs once they are in position to challenge for a place in the Finals.