sportscoach
RD's Guardians PR Man!
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2016
- Messages
- 21,153
- Reaction score
- 9,759
- Points
- 113
This isn’t a versus thing. That it’s pitted as such is dumb. I hope you all realize that.
Too many of you are more concerned about someone winning out or about being right about who wins out instead of wanting to see guys in the best position possible to determine if they can play or not and going from there. Which is how it should be approached when you have 3 relatively equal talents fighting for 1 spot and no one has done anything to separate themselves from each other.
You can’t play all 3 at once in a role conducive to discovering the truth about the player. If you are taking that as playing favorites or committing to someone or a versus thing you’re looking at it wrong.
Now, if we want to have a discussion about moving guys to make it so you can play all of your choices more frequently, that’s a topic I’d be open to as something more realistic.
Thats on me, and this was more getting the convo about the MIF in a thread of its own rather than in the main threads...
Also, all three guys have been ranked with the same FV at some point...
Freeman has the best contact skills of the three and maybe the best floor, but has the lowest ceiling since he is doesn't have much power and likely has the weakest arm...
Rocchio is a switch hitter, who does everything well... May lack the arm you exactly want from SS and always wish for a few more HRs than he may give, but otherwise no true weaknesses...
Arias has the lowest floor but the highest ceiling...
Aka I wanted to get a discussion on who is the MIF combo in 24... I just setup that way since it would be better for clickbait lol