Rich
Saucin'
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2010
- Messages
- 45,714
- Reaction score
- 70,117
- Points
- 148
For what it's worth, Sagarin has Alabama 5th in SOS, well ahead of each Big 10 team.
To your point, I'd argue that teams benefiting from playing in weaker conferences tends to balance out over time. Ask last year's National Champions about that. With that said, I will always believe if you win a Power 5 conference championship that you're a pretty damn good team, so I have no problem there. With that said, under my scenario Bama and the Big Ten champion would be locks and either OSU or the MSU/Iowa loser would have a great chance of getting in.
Well I guess we just have to disagree here. One of these days one of those really mediocre to bad teams from a shit division is going to win their title game in fluke fashion. UCLA made it to the Pac 12 title game a few years ago at like 6-6. The ACC Coastal division normally puts forth a pretty mediocre to crappy team. A couple of years ago 6-6 Georgia Tech almost won that title game (21-15). Looking at their record, that was a team that lost by TWENTY ONE points to Middle Tennessee, AT HOME.
Good teams can have a bad game and lose in the title game, even to bad teams. If we were talking about more than 8 playoff spots, I'd be ok with letting 6-6 Georgia Tech into the playoff, but I think it would be pretty shitty to allow a team like that slip through when there would be so many obviously better choices to take. Just my opinion, though.