BimboColesHair
Hall-of-Famer
- Joined
- Dec 31, 2011
- Messages
- 22,771
- Reaction score
- 59,399
- Points
- 148
hold it against me if you like, but no stats are going to convince me that dion waiters is a better defender than avery bradley, or even close to his level.
somehow I got a feeling I'm not alone in this once you go outside a cavs forum.
but it's not just defense in general, and I couldn't care less about how waiters defends small forwards - it's about guard ball pressure.
that's what blatt loves more than anything from his backcourt, that's where bradley is elite, and that's where I think waiters falls short.
Give me a better way to measure someones defensive prowess then. I'm not going to trust the infamous RCF "eye test" when it can be biased, nor will I trust "outside opinions" who have maybe seen Dion play twice so far in his career, but I damn sure will trust what their opponents put up on them and how their teams performed when they were on/off the court. Over the entirety of their career, yes Bradley is the better defender, you will have no trouble convincing me of that, but he was not as good as years past last year while Dion made large strides on that side of the ball. Show me any stat from last season that shows Avery Bradley was a better defender than Dion. You'll have trouble finding some. And if you don't trust 82games stats for defenders, here is the order of the top 5 defensive SGs (at stopping opposing SGs, according to opponent PER) from a season ago according to them: Danny Green (8.8), Thabo Sefolosha (10.7), Jimmy Butler (11), Lance Stephenson (11), Gerald Henderson (11.1)...and the guy everyone believes is one of the better young perimeter defenders in the league, Klay Thompson, went 8.4 vs PGs, 12.4 vs SGs, and 10.5 vs SFs. To me, an opinion doesn't make sense if the stats don't back up the opinion in sports. Then it just becomes a preference. Also, that is a pretty good list of guys regarded as good perimeter defenders around the league...for anyone not familiar with the site, go to it...82games.com
This is not to say Dion is without his faults. Where Dion lacks is his attention to detail on rotations, getting lost starring at the ball too much when he is guarding off the ball, and letting a previous poor trip on the offensive end distract him on the defensive side of the ball. Those are all cleared up with maturity and a strong veteran voice, which we finally have on this team for the first time, something Dion has been missing during his time in Cleveland. But as others have alluded to, he made great strides as an on ball defender last year, and the stats back up what others saw from him when he was locked in on defense.