Nope. I'm sure it's not.
Just curious as to your take because you'd described the anti-Islam cartoons as bigotry.
What are your standards for bigotry?
If David Cross jokingly says, "You know what I hate...niggers," to shock a crowd and later expressed distaste for racism, does that make him a bigot?
I honestly have no idea who David Cross is.. I guess it would depend on the situation.
However, in this situation there is no doubt that this publication was indeed quite bigoted and prejudiced towards Arabs and Blacks.
You're describing someone presumably satirizing and/or making light of the racial status quo in our society. That's not what these guys were doing.
Or if Dave Chapelle rips white people for being uptight, racist and shitty at dancing?
Funny you mention Dave Chapelle.
I remember in 2006 telling my friends:
"How can you watch this step and fetch-it Uncle Tom bastard ridicule African-Americans in front of a bunch of White folks?
What the fuck is this shit?!? Turn this shit off!!!"
Everyone thought I was just being "gour..." But you know what happened? The fucking guy finally realized what was going on and even said that was one of the reasons he walked away from the show.
I could care less... but, yeah, I found Dave Chapelle offensive as fuck -- and it didn't have anything to do with offending Whites.
Basically...if something is stated or drawn in a comedic sense, what separates bigotry from pure parody?
I assume intent?
Yep.
I ask because I'm trying to figure out what's wrong with a satirical magazine making fun of Islam, if it was in good fun.
Best of luck...
I firmly believe in the freedom of speech. So to me, there is nothing legally wrong with it. But it is offensive.
Jokes can be offensive. Doesn't matter if the person is trying to be funny or not...
If someone comes up to me and starts rambling off Black jokes, that's not going to end well. Even if he thought it was a way to be funny...
Not funny to me.
Someone post the cartoons, please. Were they genuinely bad?
They've had some really foul cartoons.
And were they in the mix with other groups being made fun of?
They never made fun of the majority of their readers... just the folks they didn't think would be buying an issue to begin with.
And did the group making fun of all other groups also make fun of themselves?
No.