Amazing performance by Butler that I did not expect. Statistically has to be one of the best in Finals history, right? 40 point triple double on 70% shooting to win a crucial game for your underdog team?
Butler clearly outdueled Lebron in the 4th quarter, playing a very similar "point forward" role. Lebron looked geared up for his own history-making performance after he almost singlehandedly kept LA in it in the 3rd. I think LBJ appreciated the moment and would have loved to put on a series-clinching performance where he showed he was better than Butler. But then in the fourth all the problems with Lebron's old man game on offense showed up. He just doesn't have the quickness or burst any more to reliably get to the basket every time, so it's very hard for him to put a team on his back and score every time down against a good defense. That really showed up on some of those turnovers.
As Butler's best game ever, this game really helped me appreciate the case for claiming him as a superstar. Bear in mind this is a guy who has never made it higher than an all-NBA third team, so he has never been officially judged to be a top 10 player in the league. You can see why that is, because he doesn't have any single "freak" talent -- he's not unbelievably athletic, not an unbelievably accurate shooter, doesn't come off as unstoppable on offense, etc. But he's kind of good at everything at once. He's not the quickest guy in the league, but he's very quick for someone so big. He's not the strongest guy in the league, but he's very quick for someone so strong. He's not the greatest passer in the league, but he's a superb passer for someone whose such an offensive threat. etc. And his mental game is tremendous! Never gets rattled, keeps a very upbeat attitude, picks up on what his team needs and just does it, whether its volume scoring, distribution, off the ball movement, or defense, and super smart in terms of things like getting fouls or responding to double-teams. Like a swiss army knife superstar.