Just looking at some WAR numbers at ESPN now that we're about done.
Gimenez has overtaken Jose for the team lead at 5.4. Defense was the difference as Jose has better offensive numbers across the board. Jose's WAR is 5.2. In third place is Kwan at 3.8 and after that it's a big dropoff to Josh Naylor at 2.4 in 118 games, or about three-fourths of a season. It seems to me that a .306 BA and 97 RBI's plus very good defense should be worth more than 2.4, especially when you consider his ability to get big hits late, but what do I know?
Will Brennan has a 0.5 WAR despite getting 429 at-bats, probably because he only hits singles, never walks (16 this year!), and is just OK defensively and on the bases.
Amed Rosario was a -0.2 in 94 games. Like Brennan he had no power, but his bad defense at a key position made him the worst starter we had this year. His replacement, Gabe Arias, was a -0.1 in 122 games. He hit .210, led the team in strikeouts, and rarely drew a walk. He also had a lower slugging percentage than Rosario, surprisingly.
Oscar Gonzalez has the lowest WAR (-1.3) in just 52 games. He couldn't hit, field, or do anything really. Sponge Bob's game was exposed as being full of holes.
Ramon Laureano had a 0.4 WAR in 38 games for the Guardians. That's a halfway decent 1.2 WAR when projected to 114 games, which is what he would probably get if he is on the team next year. Straw has a 0.8 WAR in 145 games. That .588 OPS is embarassing.
Finally, Bo Naylor has a 1.4 WAR in 64 games despite a slow start. Multiply by two (assuming he plays 128 games next year) and that's a 2.8 WAR. Bo hit just .179 in his first 117 at-bats, but since then is 24-for-72 (.333). I don't expect him to hit .333 next season, but he won't start off like he did this year in his first exposure to major league pitching. He's made a ton of progress and I think he has a great chance of being a 4+ WAR player in his first full season next year.