Because lineups simply aren’t constructed the same way they were back in Babe’s day, when it was mainly: “Put the fastest hitter at the top, the good bat control guy second, and your best hitters third and fourth,” no matter whether those first two hitters could actually hit, or even get on base. Instead, the trend over the last decade has been about getting your best hitters as many plate appearances as you can, as often as you can, which means not putting lesser hitters in front of better hitters.
It means great hitters bat first. It means great hitters bat second, too.
Simply look around the sport today and see how lineups are put together. Ronald Acuña Jr. hits leadoff. So does Mookie Betts, and Christian Yelich, and Kyle Schwarber, and George Springer, and Adley Rutschman. Freddie Freeman hits second, just like Mike Trout, Aaron Judge, Corey Seager and Paul Goldschmidt. Julio Rodríguez and Shohei Ohtani have bounced between the top two spots. If he played today, you might just have seen the Babe hitting second, too.
If the trend has accelerated over the last decade, and it has, then it’s truly reached a tipping point in 2023.
If Babe Ruth were starring for the Yankees today, he might not be wearing his legendary No. 3, famously issued to him when the team first put uniform numbers on their backs in 1929 simply because that’s where he had primarily batted in the lineup: third. Instead, imagine a world
www.mlb.com