Chunt right now.
If your question is “based on Baker’s current performance, would I prefer if the Browns run Chunt up the middle on fourth and short instead of have Baker throw downfield,” it’s yes.
If the question is, “would I prefer if the Browns run Chunt up the middle in a standard formation with no motion vs something more exotic?” The answer is no.
If the question is, “prior to Baker’s current slide, would you prefer running Chunt up the middle to Baker throwing?” it’s no again.
I distrust Baker currently. I trust Stefanski and the run game. If Baker gets healthy (assuming that’s the problem and not brain farts or OBJ), then I have no problem with some wacky formations and motion or Baker passing on 3rd and 4th and short.