@Chris Parker
Let me first say that once again, you have provided an excellent article. My only constructive criticism needs a preface: I don't listen to the media at large nor read the major publications.
Criticism: Now it might just be me, but I don't see why you would waste keystrokes bringing up other reporters at all. I liken it to feeding the trolls, but mostly, I just think it waters down your insights about the game: I absolutely LOVE your screen grabs and explanations, and you always take the game's inner-battles a step further than I am able to. It really is quality basketball insight, but never too deep that one gets bored, probably because your writing style is so witty. So if I am you, I just let the other guys say what they will (yet, another RCFer was so happy that you called them out, so maybe it is important?). I just love when you get into the nuts & bolts of the game breakdown. Also, for this article, I thought a title like "JR goes off, the Cavs' defense stays on" would be much more fitting as a theme. Consequently, going with the media-based title and intro, your conclusion was but 1 sentence to come back to your headline - like the "wrap up" part suffered, IMO.
Look, I am not a writer, nor do I know whether or not you care for the constructive bits (so let me know - I am perfectly happy to talk basketball instead), and I certainly am not telling you how to do your job. I only wrote it to help and hear your thoughts back. Overall, you did and continue to do a smash up job, so keep up the great work and I am truly excited to see your career take off.
In fact, after thinking about it, this will probably be the last "constructive criticism" that I'll post. We'll see your response, but from here on out, I'll just PM. I think it takes away from how well you did, but I'll just post it this once to see what everyone thinks...
I'm a huge simpsons fan and my favorite line in all of the world was when Homer uttered this piece of unimpeachable wisdom: "Sometimes the only way to feel better about yourself is to make someone else feel worse and I'm tired of making other people feel better."
similarly, I am reminded of Bart said to Chief Clancy Wiggum (when Sideshow Bob married & tried to kill Selma):
"I don't want to tell you how to do your job, chief" and Wiggum replied "How am I supposed to learn?"
The fact that the current beats are so immune to suggestion or criticism and feedback is a sign to me.
I appreciate your point and will try to take it to heart. However in this particular instance I simply felt this couldn't go on in good faith. I didn't call him out in "print" or even on "twitter" after Dave McMenamin called me out in person for not putting his twitter in the comment when I called out his stupid question. ("Does having Kevin Love there at the game have some intangible effect" It's the playoffs for crissakes, and if it did I'd be tremendously worried. What else has an intangible effect? did LeBron's kids sass him that morning? etc.)
But honestly, I don't know how Jason Lloyd gets away with running a story on how shitty the coach is after what we witnessed with Mike Brown & Byron Scott (who I understand are much nice, less "arrogant" people if significantly challenged by the moniker "good coach"). To go to one of the least savvy basketball minds in the game for his hit-piece -- on the eve of the first game?? -- Isaih Thomas, well, I guess you could say I was personally offended in the way I am sort of personally offended by shitty questions. Listen I have an advantage on these guys because I've interviewed 1500 or so musicians in the last decade or so. I know what a good question is through trial and error. But it's personally uncomfortable listening to these guys ask a question it sounds like they came up with 30 seconds ago.
to ask a good questions you really need to consider what the possible responses are. this is common sense but all the time there are lame questions, with tepid responses becuase they didn't ask anything that could be answered with anything substantive. Hell, I'm still trying to improve the phrasing so I can better pin people into answering. the impressions I get -- and hopefully I'm wrong -- is that these guys aren't looking over their shoulder in the least, and it's resulted in some pretty shitty sports coverage -- something I thought last year when I was sitting where you are.
then there's the fact that I believe basketball is an interesting sport without a lot of TMZ-SPN type of coverage. And to what end? None of these anti-Blatt stories had any substantive center. They're all inuendo and parsing of comments and slant. If you have to do that much work to paint a guy into the corner, how about you put that effort into actually covering the sport.
So as you can see, this is something about which I feel something. From writing about music so long I've concluded that if you aren't doing what's in yr heart then you're kind of a hack. That's only me, others may feel pride in what they do, but for me, if I'm not feeling it I shouldn't be doing it. As I've said before this gives me a lot more leeway than most of my peers who are worried if they say something bad about NEOMG or ESPN their career will be screwed. I am a writer not a sports reporter so there is very little chance that the animosity I assume Brian Windhorst feels toward me having any impact on my life choices in the least. Not everyone has that luxury which is probably why Cavs coverage looks like a bunch of dogs smelling each other's ass.
that said, I really agree with you. I'd SO MUCH rather just write about Xs & Os. I played some hoops in H.S. but I can learn/know so much more, so I feel like explaining what I see and talking to Campy and Chonesy and anyone else willing/able to provide some insight into this incredibly complex game , so I might understand it more and help others enjoy it how I do -- as this rare sport that's very complex and yet very simple and which more than anything I can think of outside crew -- relies on people working in concert as a team. (Football with its prescribed roles and hierarchy feels more like an oligarchy than basketball's democracy where everyone is expected to do a little of everything to some extent)
However all this other noise intrudes on this conversation, indeed threatens to drown it out to my thinking (I'm probably wrong, but that's how it feels when they slash Blatt but fail to write anything about game strategy. I'm like how does that work? Does Blatt only call timeouts??Because judging from the coverage, that's what you'd think. Obviously LeBron calls the plays and probaby draws up the gameplan too [facepalm]
Know that I could make more money doing what I have been doing and can only do what I'm doing because my wife has a good job and understands my needs & desires. I love stories, and LeBron's return is the best sports story to my mind since the Red Sox ended their 86 yr drought. I wanted to cover this story and everything else has flowed out of that.
I have gone on pretty long and if you got this far you are to be commended. but like music I feel there is something every important in why you do things, it is the essence of the intent that often determines the outcome. It is a lot of why I've gone at it the way I have, and why I've approached it like this. If the sports beats were more on the level of a Chicago or Boston or New York, I probably wouldn't write about stupid shit like the Thomas article at all because such shit wouldn't exist and I could concentrate on filling my niche.
But I respect the sport and writing and just feel if you like what you do you should demonstrate that by giving back. When you can't and you just become a bitter hack maybe it's time for a look in the mirror and a break. Of course that won't happen so we'll probably always have a need for a gadfly like me.
oh ,and by the way, in case you didn't know, the other beat writers are aware of this site, but apparently are above it. I don't know, maybe they feel they know more than you. (And they complain blatt "thinks he's the smartest guy in the room." you'd think they'd digest that lesson on humility but ....)
So yes, jason Lloyd if you are reading this and you didn't get from my article that I thought your piece on Thomas was a huge ugly dump on Blatt and the team itself, now you know, and you know that even if you refuse to talk to me and badmouth to the other beats, I'm not going to suddenly be cowed and back off. I don't expect you to care, but just know I don't either and though you're one of the finest beat writers I will not shy from telling you when I believe your full of shit. As the Dude says, "its just like my opinion, man."
So yeah, thanks so much for the comments about my breakdowns. Sometimes I write pieces after watching the game over, sometimes like today, I know what I want to say and then bring out the other stuff. But know that after spending a couple hours on the prose I go and do the analysis. I couldn't get my slingbox to work so I had to work with different video sources which was more difficult and confused things. But i felt I owed it to you guys to offer what breakdowns I could. I promise they'll be better when I'm in Ohio and the internet lag handling streaming video coming from my home DVR isn't so egregious.
I feel we have a pact. you support me and I try to give you something you won't get otherwise. I LOVE this deal. I hope I can keep you feeling the same way.