I think some of this is circumstance though. Cade was born in America, so his route is different than Luka's. So I'm not sure why that is held against him, in regard to evaluating them as prospects? It is impossible to say how Cade or any #1 American player would favor over seas at 18 but I suspect it is far better than most think.
What I was alluding to was this:
One sites' opinion......but they grade so similarly.......6/12 categories they grade out as equals, 5/12 within 1 number grade. I think most would be surprised to see that Cade gets the nod in defense, leadership and potential.
I'm really curious to watch how Cade plays with some college experience. I think he's more of a guy who will gain steam through consistent play over time, vs. being a prospect that is going to wow someone athletically, or on a minute by minute basis as they watch games. Most were unimpressed in a game where he went for 21/10/3, made 2 threes and went to the line 7 times. Imagine what his A+ game looks like if everyone felt that was a B- or so.
I know you like him, I'm more just talking through how perception can swing so quickly from game to game. What made Cade the #1 player was how consistently he performed in HS and USA events. That floor really stands out over time and I would imagine it takes hold and that separation really starts to happen after 10 games or so.
Are these ratings realistic, though?
For example, assuming Cade is on the right hand side, he has the edge in "leadership." But Doncic led a pro team to multiple championships by age 19. I don't know how a prospect could possibly show more leadership ability than Doncic did. Similarly with potential...I don't know how a prospect could possibly show more potential than Doncic did. He planted his flag on all the highest mountains in the sport outside of the NBA.
I also want to focus on passing. Cade is a good passer, probably good enough to play point forward. But Doncic's gotta be in the top 2 or 3 best prospects of the last decade in terms of pure passing ability. Anyone who gives them the same grade there just hasn't done their homework.