• Changing RCF's index page, please click on "Forums" to access the forums.

Ex Indians update

Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Does the 2 cy youngs make him a HOFer? or just not enough with the lack of wins over his career?
 
Does the 2 cy youngs make him a HOFer? or just not enough with the lack of wins over his career?
I don't think he'll get there because most voters consider total career/longevity and Kluber really just had 6-7 full years. Johan Santana is probably a similar comp and he received only 2.4% his first year and was removed off the ballot. Best chance is probably the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee voting him in sometime down the road. It seems hard to believe the arguably the best pitcher in baseball for ~5 year stretch has no chance.

Kluber might be my favorite player of all time. Sad to see him go.
 
Does the 2 cy youngs make him a HOFer? or just not enough with the lack of wins over his career?

Further reading, not entirely about HOF, but provides additional context to his timeline.

I'll leave the HOF to the forum elders and baseball historians tucked among us to dive into as it'd be a discussion worthy of tapping back into his thread here on RCF. Am not qualified to pass judgment upon such, as the age old career pillars/achievements/requirements for admission aren't my wheelhouse!
 
Does the 2 cy youngs make him a HOFer? or just not enough with the lack of wins over his career?

He will get in the Cleveland Indians/Guardians hall of fame in a sense but not in the regular one....

A hall of famer is like 70ish bWAR if not more... He's got 34 bWAR... Tim Hudson had 200+ wins and 55 bWAR and didn't even get a vote... He will make the ballot, but won't get enough votes to stay on...
 
Crazy day to be a Tom Mastny fan…. Congrats to him…
 
Think I might just start calling the Tampa Rays "Guardians South'...

 
Think I might just start calling the Tampa Rays "Guardians South'...

They also did Yu Chang earlier .... they know how to get talent out of our rejects.

Nice break the bank contract ... 9 figures ... err a bit over (closer to) league min
 

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Video

Episode 3-14: "Time for Playoff Vengeance on Mickey"

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Spotify

Episode 3:14: " Time for Playoff Vengeance on Mickey."
Top