(I had nowhere else to put these thoughts so why not.)
As a big Frasier fan, decided to give the revival a shot. Did not like what I was hearing about the story decisions but wanted to try to put that to the side and see how the show is. As many have noted, David Hyde Pierce meant so much to the original run, but the man didn't want to come back (understandably) so the show must go on I guess. I've only watched the first episode which had to explain a lot about the current state of things, so it could improve as they find their footing, but it's pretty bad to start.
Kelsey Grammar is still Frasier, although they could have used some more high society snobbish references to give him something to chew on. Unfortunately, the rest of the cast feels like they are floundering around him. You have:
-New Freddy, who doesn't feel smart like young Freddy nor tough like a Boston firefighter. He's just... guy.
-David, the son of Niles who acts more like Rodney Banks from that Mixed Doubles episode. DHP was a master physical comedian and they introduce this character by having him try to carry a large piece of luggage unsuccessfully. A fine set up, but there was no pay off, it was just kinda awkward.
-Eve, Freddy's single mother friend who's also an actor (but they didn't find a good one to play her... sorry).
-Alan, the over-it tenured professor who has
some potential as a straight man to Frasier.
-Harvard lady, who is weird and off-putting.
Things I would've done differently:
- Set it in Chicago or back in Seattle. Going back to Boston feels... off. Cheers FELT like Boston, this show just feels like brightly lit sitcom #25487.
- Switch Freddy and David's characters. We already knew Freddy and he was played by a good actor who went on to do a part on Mad Men. Instead of a reverse Martin situation where now Frasier lives with his blue collar son, make that David's role. He's a blank slate who's half Moon anyway! Then you could still do the odd couple cousins thing and the Frasier-Freddy relationship could be more akin to Frasier-Niles instead of Martin (nobody in this cast seems like a normal person the way John Mahoney did, so there isn't enough contrast to hoity toity Frasier). They went out of their way to create strain in their relationship, when you could've dug in to the fact that Frasier spent Freddy's childhood on the other side of the country. It's right there.
- They have a storyline that Harvard lady NEEDS Frasier to teach at Harvard to prop up their Psych department... Why? Frasier is set up as a former talk show host, not a brilliant researcher. Is Harvard worried about their med school because they haven't reeled in Dr. Oz? How about instead you set things at a smaller college. She could kind of play a Dean Pelton on Community role where she's desperate to make a name for her little school in a town with Harvard & MIT. This would also give us something to LIKE about her. As is, she's a wound-tight Harvard staffer who's oddly obsessed with Frasier, with no funny lines.
- Make Frasier miserable! His Dad just died, he's recently divorced, and he just seems fine with his life in the new show. Why are we telling this story? Well, it could be an inflection point in his life where he needs to make a change because he's lost everything he built (maybe he gets fired from the TV show or... something!) Instead he takes the Harvard job and stays in Boston because he wants to force Freddy to live with him. If you're gonna do that, maybe put Freddy into more dire straits than being a firefighter? Why isn't the baby his? At least that would give Frasier a reason to think Freddy needs more direction & support in his life.
- Find some other deal for Eve. At the end of the reboot pilot, she's living rent free across the hall. So what's the point? I assume she'll still be a regular but there's no real reason to have her in the story if it's not Freddy's kid and she's not Freddy's GF or even roommate anymore.
Hopefully with the exposition out of the way they can get some better jokes in and let them breathe. The pacing was especially forced.