My ten
Mark Buerhle
Tim Hudson
Curt Schilling
Andruw Jones
Scott Rolen
Jeff Kent
Not question is, do I believe the Mitchell report?...
If I do then Helton, Abreu, Ortiz, Pettitte, Bonds, Clemens, Ramirez, A-Rod, Sheffield, Sosa, etc are all out... Pudge though got voted in even though he was in it....Now Manny, A-Rod, Sosa I believe all got caught and Ortiz, Pettitte admitted to using then if I recall correctly... Pettitte though has 250 wins...
On paper numbers wise Vizquel and Hunter both have similar careers, GG with solid but not spectacular hitting numbers... Vizquel is in legal troubles though... Rollins has more WAR than Vizquel but less GGs... if you put in Wagner do you not have to put in a John Franco?
Everyone else is out in my mind...
So to be fair, those 6... if I had to choose ten, then I would go Hunter, Sheffield, Vizquel and Helton...
Abreu and wagner are 11 and 12...
I'd vote Vizquel as a baseball player since honestly when it comes to SS defense, hard to say he wasn't top 5 all time...
I personable do believe Bonds and Clemens used something for long period of times, so I couldn't personally vote them in...