There's the rub.
What kind of #1 and #2 do you have that can play well enough without the ball? 29% usage is approaching Steph Curry, Kevin Durant and Lebron James territory. But if you dial back the usage for Collin, you aren't offsetting his defense w/24 PPG anymore. As a 3rd guy, Collin is looking at 21-24% usage, and probably something like 14-16 PPG/2-3 APG.
When you think of how he plays and the demands of the ball within the context of how he plays, you see why people see his best role as a high end second unit scorer and late game closer at times.
There isn't an example of a 2nd unit guy who scores as well as he does though. So, as bad as people want that, we still need guys on the floor who can score. Plus they just added a scorer who will be the 6th man, in Lauri.
Point take on Colin's usage, but at the beginning of last year, Collin's usage was down and his scoring was up. Once multiple backup pg's went down, and Garland was hurt yeah his usage went up.
You are basically arguing that Collin can't get his when others do, but we know that is simply not true. Garland's best games came when they were both playing well and Collin "just" got 20 or 22. In those spurs games where Garland went ham, Garland score 37 and Collin got 22. In the other one they both scored 29. Even in the Boston game where Love scored 30 to win it, Collin was right there with 28. Same when Okoro scored 32 against the Suns, Collin was right there with 28. He let Okoro lead the charge and was putting the ball in his hands. I have never seen Collin take the ball out of a teammates hands when they were hot. He defers when a guy has it going.
I don't think there is any basis to say that Collin is taking touches from anyone to the detriment of the team. When other guys are hot, he can play a secondary role or also blast out a nice scoring night. If a guy is hot, it seems not to affect him or if anything make his job easier to cruise to a nice scoring night even while being overshadowed.
2 of our best young prospects in Darius and Mobley are playmakers. You need scorers like Collin around those guys.
I mean remember when Kyrie was taking the ball out of our best players hands because his usage was so high? Lowest with Lebron was 29.5. Same year Irving blew Collin's assist numbers away with a 4.7 instead of 4.4 assists. It was the worst of Irving career to be fair.
Kyrie was still one of Lebron's very best teammates because he was able to take advantage of the man's playmaking consistently. I expect something similar from Collin this year as his usage dips, and his teammates are better playmakers.