Apparently a very good scout of players, but a lousy manager. I mean, in terms of him getting a GM job, his resume includes strongly preferring Freddie Kitchens over Kevin Stefanski.
Would you really want to put a guy like that in charge of your organization?
Also, while he might be very good at some aspects of talent evaluation, he's also the guy who decided that Hubbard and Robinson were acceptable starting tackles, and when he made a major trade, further depleted the offensive line and our draft capital in favor of drafting a WR who hasn't made much of a difference here. Bottom line is that it was Dorsey's decisions that led to Baker having a terrible season.